The AE911Truth Petition
To the Members of the House of Representatives and of the Senate of the United States of America,
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT:
On Behalf of the People of the United States of America, the undersigned Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth and affiliates hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 – specifically the collapses of the World Trade Center Towers and Building 7. We believe there is sufficient doubt about the official story and therefore the 9/11 investigation must be re-opened and must include a full inquiry into the possible use of explosives that might have been the actual cause of the destruction of the World Trade Center Twin Towers and Building 7.
Featured Petition Signers
Michael J. Lobuglio, AIA
Architect
Virginia Tech
I hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 ' specifically the…
Michael J. Lobuglio, AIA
Virginia Tech
Newtown, CT
Occupation: Architect
I am the principal of Michael Lobuglio Architects where we specialize in residential architecture. I graduated from Virginia Tech School of Architecture in 1986.
I hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 ' specifically the collapses of the World Trade Center Towers and Building 7.
Edward J. Misch
Mechanical Engineer
BS Engineering, Purdue University Calumet, 1974
An investigation must be done. I am convinced that building 7 was destroyed by a demolition, and not by fire. We need to understand exactly what happened. The…
Edward J. Misch
BS Engineering, Purdue University Calumet, 1974
Munster, IN
Occupation: Mechanical Engineer
My engineering degree from Purdue University is interdisciplinary, and I was licensed for more than 30 years. I have worked under the direct supervision of a licensed structural engineer for many years. I have 40 years of engineering experience designing upgrades, repairs, and modifications to steel mill equipment.
An investigation must be done. I am convinced that building 7 was destroyed by a demolition, and not by fire. We need to understand exactly what happened. The responsibility of a Professional Engineer is to ensure public safety.
Spencer B. Graves, PhD, PE
Engineer And Statistician
BS Aerospace Engineering, University Colorado-Boulder, 1967; MS Industrial Engineering, University Pittsburgh, 1972
The way building 7 collapsed (apparently in sympathy with the twin towers) raises huge questions about the official narrative. Reports of suppression of evidence for the earlier 9/11…
Spencer B. Graves, PhD, PE
BS Aerospace Engineering, University Colorado-Boulder, 1967; MS Industrial Engineering, University Pittsburgh, 1972
Overland Park, KS
Occupation: Engineer And Statistician
BS Aerospace Engineering, University Colorado-Boulder, 1967; MS Industrial Engineering, University Pittsburgh, 1972; MA Mathematics, University Missouri-Kansas City, 1975; PhD Statistics, University Wisconsin-Madison, 1983. My PE license was obtained based on my MS in industrial engineering and 3+ years of industrial engineering experience as an officer in the US Air Force 1968-1973. I've been practicing in engineering statistics from 1982 to the present. I worked with Hewlett Packard, then taught Industrial and Systems Engineering at San Jose State. I consulted for the low emissions partnership of Ford, General Motors and Chrysler, then with PDF Solutions in San Jose, CA. I was president of a start-up to do real time monitoring of engineering structures and am now with VivoSecurity, another California start-up. I'm the author of 2 books and 3 patents (plus one more pending). I have over 30 published technical papers, and my software is used all over the world.
The way building 7 collapsed (apparently in sympathy with the twin towers) raises huge questions about the official narrative. Reports of suppression of evidence for the earlier 9/11 commission as well as other evidence kept from the public from events decades earlier make it easy to question the official story.
Susumu Kuwano, Architect
degreed & licensed
I am not agreeing with you 100% on how the buildings have collapsed, but I do agree with it needs the new investigation.
Susumu Kuwano, Architect
degreed & licensed
NerimaKu, Tokyo, Japan
1969, Dec Tokyo first class authorized architect qualification. 1966, Apl Entering a company KOKEN ARCHITECTS INC. made some station building in Japan. 2002, Nov retire of the company 2003, Apl make own company'' Kuwano Design
I am not agreeing with you 100% on how the buildings have collapsed, but I do agree with it needs the new investigation.
Tony E. Rooke
Writer
College
Under British Law [and US] we have now surpassed the legal criteria of 'reasonable cause' to believe 9/11 was what is known as a 'false flag' terror event.…
Tony E. Rooke
College
Chichester, United Kingdom
Occupation: Writer
10 years research into the events of 9/11. Director of film 'INCONTROVERTIBLE' which interviews police officers, soldiers, firefighters, politicians, and other law enforcers over their doubts concerning the official 9/11 cover-up.
Under British Law [and US] we have now surpassed the legal criteria of 'reasonable cause' to believe 9/11 was what is known as a 'false flag' terror event. The evidence by FAR points to US Government collusion and cover-up with as yet unknown agents conducting this event for political leverage in aiding America's foreign policy of middle-east aggression.
Howard T. Hartman
Mechanical
B.S.M.E. University of Colorado
1) Building 7; 2) Fairly freefall of all buildings ; 3) first ever steel frame failure from fire x 3 @ same day ; 4) Eye/Ear witness accounts…
Howard T. Hartman
B.S.M.E. University of Colorado
Broomfield, CO
Occupation: Mechanical
Have always worked in Residential construction. Attained engineering degree from CU while working in construction. Started construction business and bought and altered prints for and built my own home. Still running successful roofing company in Denver.
1) Building 7; 2) Fairly freefall of all buildings ; 3) first ever steel frame failure from fire x 3 @ same day ; 4) Eye/Ear witness accounts of timely explosions ; 5) anomalous treatment of powdered concrete crime scene ; 6) presence of molten metal ; 7) considering who benefits - many curious coincidences on the money /political spectrum.
Bernard G. Stroh, BS
Structural Engineer
BS Civil/Structural Engineering, North Dakota State University Fargo, 1975
With my extensive acquired knowledge and practical experience in structural engineering design (over 39 years), I have always doubted the official reports regarding the cause of the collapses…
Bernard G. Stroh, BS
BS Civil/Structural Engineering, North Dakota State University Fargo, 1975
Kula, HI
Occupation: Structural Engineer
I received my bachelors' degree in civil/structural engineering in 1975 from North Dakota State University in Fargo, North Dakota. Since 1975, I have been actively engaged in the practice of structural engineering for buildings of all types and sizes across the United States. I hold active licenses in most midwest states and other states from coast to coast. I am also currently working on many projects in Haiti including schools, clinics, churches and hospitals.
With my extensive acquired knowledge and practical experience in structural engineering design (over 39 years), I have always doubted the official reports regarding the cause of the collapses of the WTC site buildings. I wholeheartedly sign the petition to open the investigation with an unbiased, objective review regardless of where the conclusions may lead. This petition with the credentials of the professional signers may be unprecedented in modern history.
Richard Tanner
Electrical Engineer
B.S. Engineering, Arkansas State University, 2003,
Many unknowns or questionable answers still remain in regards to September 11, 2001, particularly in regards to Building 7. A proper and public investigation should have been done…
Richard Tanner
B.S. Engineering, Arkansas State University, 2003,
Little Rock, AR
Occupation: Electrical Engineer
Bachelor of Science in Engineering, 2003. Entire engineering career spent in consulting engineering for electrical systems in building construction.
Many unknowns or questionable answers still remain in regards to September 11, 2001, particularly in regards to Building 7. A proper and public investigation should have been done and would still be beneficial.
Thomas A. Nagy
Writer
writer
Thomas A. Nagy
writer
Portland, OR
Occupation: Writer
Researcher and author, long a student of politics and its influence on the world view. This research and personal experience with various bodies of government led to the conclusions expressed in Placebo Politics and Empty Elections as the subtle, dryly humorous perspective of modern domestic and international politics. The key to understanding Placebo Politics is to be acutely aware of the hidden agenda behind every action ...
Heidi Elston
Retired Housekeeper
Have always been fascinated by watching the controlled collapses of buildings on T.V. So when I witnessed the 911 collapses, I became immediately suspicious. ANYONE could see the…
Heidi Elston
Jamestown, CA
Occupation: Retired Housekeeper
Disabled American that knows there's more to this story. An American who is sad and disillusioned, but not afraid to peel this onion back!
Have always been fascinated by watching the controlled collapses of buildings on T.V. So when I witnessed the 911 collapses, I became immediately suspicious. ANYONE could see the similarities! Thanx Mom for giving me all those midnight lectures on the corruptness of government back in 1972!
Jeff Bell, MS, BS
Structural Engineer
Bachelor of Science, Civil Engineering, University of Kansas, 2011; M.S. Structural Engineering, University of Kansas, 2012
All evidence supports controlled demolition. This includes reports of multiple explosions by witnesses in and around the buildings, visual video evidence of squibs and other horizontal ejections, thermite…
Jeff Bell, MS, BS
Bachelor of Science, Civil Engineering, University of Kansas, 2011; M.S. Structural Engineering, University of Kansas, 2012
Overland Park, KS
Occupation: Structural Engineer
BS - Civil Engineering-2011 MS - Structural Engineering-2012
All evidence supports controlled demolition. This includes reports of multiple explosions by witnesses in and around the buildings, visual video evidence of squibs and other horizontal ejections, thermite particles found in the dust, high temperature fires in the pile, and the free fall speed of the collapse. Building 7 displays even more characteristics of controlled demolition. None of the evidence supports the towers fell due to fire and/or plane impact.
J Kevin Vogel, P.e., BSME
Semi-retired
BS Mechanical Engineering, University of Santa Clara, 1964
The physical evidence for the destruction of Building #7 flatly contradicts the conclusions of the official inquiry.
J Kevin Vogel, P.e., BSME
BS Mechanical Engineering, University of Santa Clara, 1964
Post Falls, ID
Occupation: Semi-retired
BSME, University of Santa Clara, 1964. I spent 35 years in the electrical industry designing electrical distribution and controls for industrial, commercial, and residential facilities.
The physical evidence for the destruction of Building #7 flatly contradicts the conclusions of the official inquiry.
Petition Signatories
Ryan G. Van Leuven, Engineer Intern
Logan, UT
Education: BS Civil Engineering, Boise State
Ryan G. Van Leuven, Engineer Intern
BS Civil Engineering, Boise State
Logan, UT
Received my B.S. Degree in Civil Engineering from Boise State in May of 2009 with an emphasis in Structural and Geo technical Engineering. I am currently working on my M.S. Degree in Civil Engineering at Utah State University emphasizing in Geo technical Engineering. I have held several intern positions at various firms during my undergraduate work and received my Engineering Intern certification in 2009 and plan to earn my P.E. certification in 2013.
I have concerns about how the buildings collapsed in the manner that they did given the circumstances. I believe that a structural failure of that magnitude should be given much more investigation and inquiry then it received before a conclusion was made by the commission. They way the buildings fell leave many important and pertinent questions unanswered.
Richard Linza, I.e.
Oklahoma City, OK
Education: B.S. Electrical Engineering, OSU
Richard Linza, I.e.
B.S. Electrical Engineering, OSU
Oklahoma City, OK
I am an electrical engineer, and graduate of Oklahoma Statue University.
It takes a basic understanding of high school physics to understand that twos building designed to take multiple hits from a Boeing 707 and continue to stand will be able to take a single hit from a Boeing 767, and remain standing. They will not fall straight down, at near free fall speeds minutes apart. Also two building struck at different locations will not fall in exactly the same way.
Allen B. Mclemore, PE
Springville, AL
Education: B.S. Civil Engineering Auburn University
Allen B. Mclemore, PE
B.S. Civil Engineering Auburn University
Springville, AL
B.S.Civil Engineering from Auburn University 1985 U.S. Peace Corps Volunteer 1986 - 1988 Geotechnical Engineer 1989 - 1992 Environmental Engineer1993 - Present
World Trade Center 7 appears to be a free-fall collapse. There are structural reasons to suspect that this collapse was a controlled demolition, and a serious independent investigation should occur.
Katherine E. Bewersdorf, MS
Denver, CO
Occupation: Controls Engineer
Education: M.S., Aerospace Engineering, WashU
Katherine E. Bewersdorf, MS
M.S., Aerospace Engineering, WashU
Denver, CO
Occupation: Controls Engineer
I earned my B.S. in Engineering at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign in 2002. I earned an M.S. degree in Aerospace Engineering at Washington University in St. Louis. I worked in the defense industry from 2003 to 2008 at The Boeing Company as a Controls Engineer.
My main concern here is the lack of analysis performed in the Official 9/11 Commission Report, and glaring omissions such as the collapse of 7 WTC. The Commission claimed that 1 WTC collapsed in a pancake fashion (p. 308) and that 2 WTC fell in ten seconds and collapsed into itself (p.305). Given that free fall speed for the buildings would be around 9.2 seconds, and that the law of conservation of energy would prohibit such a rapid collapse under the pancake theory, the lack of scientific evidence and analysis leaves much to be desired. Furthermore, research on the WTC dust yielded highly advanced nano-thermitic compounds, indicating the true cause of collapse of the three WTC buildings was indeed through the use of explosives (Active Thermitic Material Discovered from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe. The Open Chemical Physics Journal, 2009). That finding supports the mechanics of collapse observed, including the coincidentally high degree of symmetry, lack of rotation or bending of the upper sections of the North and South Towers above the plane impact zones during collapse, and of course the speed at which they fell. This and video evidence of sequential explosions during the towers' destruction indicate that the twin towers were brought down by systematic controlled demolition. The nature of fall and lack of structural damage to 7 WTC also indicates an organized, deliberate demolition occurred here. There is more than enough scientific evidence to cause for demand of an independent investigation of the nature of the events on 9/11/01 and an unbiased diligent effort applied into discovering who was involved.
Omid Kayvan, BS
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA
Education: BS Civil Engineering, Arizona State University, 1982
Omid Kayvan, BS
BS Civil Engineering, Arizona State University, 1982
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA
I'm a civil engineer and project manager for the FAA. I have 25 years experience building National Airspace System critical facilities, including the construction of air traffic control towers.
I have serious doubts about the cause of collapse of WTC 1 and WTC 2, as well as WTC 7. The indications are that they came down in a controlled-collapse manner, and this casts a dark shadow over the official published story. I have worked on projects involving controlled demolitions of decommissioned air traffic control towers. My opinion is that the twin towers and building 7 were brought down by controlled demolition, contrary to the official story.
Jesse D. Elliott, Safety & Quality
San Luis Obispo, CA
Occupation: Electrical Construction
Education: BS Mechanical Engineering
Jesse D. Elliott, Safety & Quality
BS Mechanical Engineering
San Luis Obispo, CA
Occupation: Electrical Construction
I am the Safety and Quality Officer for REC Solar, Inc., a solar electric system integrator of residential, commercial, and federal government projects. I set the standards and policies for all construction safety, quality, and efficient installation practices. I graduated with a BS in Mechanical Engineering from California Polytechnic Institute, San Luis Obispo. I hold an electrical contractor's license in the state of California, and a general electrical journeyman's license in the states of California and Hawaii. I am the responsible managing employee (RME) for our California market. The only active engineering I do is field engineer when going out to sites, review designs for some of our large commercial projects, or reverse engineer systems when we get quality issues to determine root causes so corrective actions can be made and sent out to the teams.
It is Sunday night, 10:31pm as I write this sentence. I just finished watching the truth about 911 video and I am very happy that there is an organization out there that is supporting finding the truth to truly hold accountable those who destroyed and killed thousands of people that day in the area of the World Trade Centers and WTC 7 building collapse. Every part of my physical and mental state of being to this point in time from all my field and academic experiences believes the evidence that was presented in the video presentation and I want and will support the cause for the truth. There are too many complacent people in the USA who want to go about struggling, living miserable existences, paycheck to paycheck, and complaining about a country that doesn't do enough for them and just not do anything about it. Mainly because they do not realize that they have been brain-washed by the media propaganda of consumerism due to the mass amounts of commercial advertising that is viewed either driving down the street, listening to the radio or seen during the countless hours of t.v watching that most Americans do. That is not me! I want to be part of the movement that stands up for what is right and true. I believe that the evidence presented in the video that I watched today has very serious implications of possibly our government and some of the biggest Corporate America companies creating the disaster that occurred to further propagate the fear that weaves itself through the American culture. This fear allows complacency, consumerism, and control for certain government official and corporate leaders to continue to gain more as the mass population gains less. That is all I have at this time.
Christine Begley, EIT
Mahwah, NJ
Education: BSCE Manhattan, MCE Villanova
Christine Begley, EIT
BSCE Manhattan, MCE Villanova
Mahwah, NJ
I earned both a Bachelor and a Master of Civil Engineering degree back in the early 90's. I did leave the field in the late 90's and have not returned to it. As far as being licensed, I do possess E.I.T. certification. At the time of the catastrophe, I did wonder why neither the USACOE nor the ASCE did not demand to investigate the site and take tests and samples, etc.., this being an unprecedented case for study in the field of Civil Engineering.
For starters, why weren't there 100+ slabs of steel reinforced concrete flooring piled one on top of the other in the rubble? How were over 100+ steel reinforced concrete floors in both towers I and II pulverized to dust within minutes? Just asking? For starters.
Johan T. Frederiksen, Engineer
Aarhus, Denmark
Education: Engineering, Aalborg University
Johan T. Frederiksen, Engineer
Engineering, Aalborg University
Aarhus, Denmark
As engineer within computer-science and electronics, I had a substantial basic teaching of Physics and Chemistry ... my specialty is self-organizing systems of which the magazine PhysicaPlus has published one of my articles.
Building 7 was clearly brought down with the use of explosives. The Twin Towers also show signs of a controlled demolition (e.g. free fall speed)
Dale Lynn, BSEE, MSEE
Freehold, NJ
Education: BSEE, MSEE
Dale Lynn, BSEE, MSEE
BSEE, MSEE
Freehold, NJ
Member of Technical Staff at Bell Laboratories for 30 years, co-inventor on 9 US Patents, private pilot
President Bush declared this to be the pivotal event of the new century. The event is used to justify two wars that have lasted longer than WW II. The official explanation is inconsistent with physical evidence.
Odette Rundle
London, London, United Kingdom
Education: B Engineering in Metallurgy, University of Pretoria South Africa
Odette Rundle
B Engineering in Metallurgy, University of Pretoria South Africa
London, London, United Kingdom
I'm a materials engineer and I studied at the University of Pretoria, South Africa. I worked in materials testing for Dorbyl Ltd and the Atomic Energy Corporation, then I moved to the UK. Since then, I have been developing software for materials testing specialist Instron Corporation and others.
I appeal to the lay person's common sense and day-to-day experience of how our physical world functions. Most people have seen footage of controlled demolitions; they are reminiscent of the behavior of the falling WTC structures. There are some serious unanswered questions in this regard. In addition, as a materials engineer, I know that steel and reinforced concrete buildings do not 'collapse' in the range of temperatures and time of exposure experienced by the WTC structures. I find the official explanation unsatisfactory and patronizing.
Roger D. Simpson, PE
Santee, CA
Roger D. Simpson, PE
Santee, CA
Registered Professional Engineer (Civil) now retired, practicing consulting engineering in California, Arizona and Nevada. Experience in highway, bridge, waterworks, and all phases of public works and building projects over a 47 year career.
I sat riveted for over two and 1/2 hours listening and watching the presentation by Mr. Richard Gage, AIA. The concise information on the twin towers and especially building 7, caused me to reevaluate the 911 Commission report. Unfortunately, that conclusion caused me to be quite concerned at the direction that the thought process then takes you. At the very least, the disaster must be investigated with new eyes on the nature and causes of the building loss and the loss of life. Who or what is responsible? How could it have been done? What part did the planes really have in the collapse? I don't know but would like more answers.
Rob Sargent, BSME, MSCIM
Chelmsford, MA
Education: BSME UNH, MSCIM BYU
Rob Sargent, BSME, MSCIM
BSME UNH, MSCIM BYU
Chelmsford, MA
Degreed Mechanical Engineer, 20 years professional design and manufacturing experience.
WTC 7 was not struck by aircraft, was quite a distance from the falling towers, from photos and video did not seem damaged or extensively on fire yet collapsed in what appears to be a controlled, engineered, pre-planned demolition. This building is the only steel framed skyscraper to ever collapse from fire. A very through investigation should have been performed, instead all steel was controlled and recycled immediately, an act of criminal destruction of evidence. The twin towers collapse is also suspect. Eyewitnesses reporting explosions before the collapse. Also the damaged structure at and above the impact zone should not have been able to collapse the remaining undamaged structure, especially the massively strong central core. The core and outer walls supported the weight of the upper structure, it would have been able to resist the dynamic force of the upper structure falling. There can not be more energy generated dynamically from falling than is present in the potential energy from standing, height x gravity x mass. If the lower supporting structure had been able to support the upper floors for thirty years plus a commercial airliner impact, it would have resisted the dynamic energy because they are the same and the weight of the upper structure has been removed from the lower, that's the only way the upper can fall. Therefore in a non-controlled collapse the top section would have remained in place or fallen and broken into many small pieces and fallen off the sides of the remaining non damaged structure. If the floors had pancaked the central core would have remained standing. The only way the collapses can occur as they did is if the central core was destroyed by controlled explosions. The central cores were systematically blown and ripped down the rest of the buildings from the inside. Again all evidence was destroyed by remelting the steel. The event known as 911 was in my opinion a combination of an external government and some members of the US Fed government conspiring to produce a domestic terrorism event (false flag) to launch the global war on terrorism resulting in the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq, the patriot act, the tapping of every piece of voice, e-mail, data communications in the world, Dept of homeland security, increase in oil prices and massive military / domestic police force spending all on the backs of the supposedly terrified US taxpayer. It is and will remain the single most important event in the history of this country.
Terry Gray, DDS
Springfield, MO
Education: DDS, BSEE, BSBE(Biomed.Eng.)
Terry Gray, DDS
DDS, BSEE, BSBE(Biomed.Eng.)
Springfield, MO
Worked in Ground and Flight Test Engineering at Boeing-Wichita for 11 years and then worked for 20 years as Biomedical Engineer at Dole VA Medical Center-Wichita,KS. Also practiced Dentistry for 4 years. Have also been involved in electronics (repair of electronic test equipment and consumer electronics) for over 50 years.
I am really impressed (and horrified) as to the masterful and deceitful demolition job that was done on the World Trade Center Complex Bldgs. 1,2,&7, especially 7, and their ability to pass this off on the majority. Superthermite, thermate, nanoparticles, remote-controlled airliners, multiple explosions/ejections in and from the buildings prior to collapse and during their non-impeded free-fall---all paid for with our tax dollars! I have viewed Bldg. 7 collapsing at least 50 times-ABSOLUTELY NO WAY WAS THIS POSSIBLE ON ITS OWN!!!! Classic and rather obvious controlled sequential demolition. They really do think we're stupid.
Adam Klein, Engineer
Redwood City, CA
Education: BS Civil Engineering, UC Davis
Adam Klein, Engineer
BS Civil Engineering, UC Davis
Redwood City, CA
Project Engineer for high end residential, commercial, industrial, and anchorage work.
After carefully looking at evidence present by others, whether supporting or not supporting the official story, I have doubts on the authenticity of what the populace was led to believe. - - - - I think the American people deserve to see a thorough, independent investigation without governmental influence or review.
Joshua M. Lange, Facilities Engin
Pawtucket, RI
Education: BA Engineering Mass Maritime Academy
Joshua M. Lange, Facilities Engin
BA Engineering Mass Maritime Academy
Pawtucket, RI
I am a 2003 graduate of Massachusetts Maritime Academy in Buzzard's Bay Mass. I graduated magna cum laude and have always excelled in the sciences including math. Professionally I have been employeed in the facilities maintenance and engineering field in the Boston area since 2003.
It seems to me that having three unprecedented collapses of ruggedly built steel buildings in one day is grounds for a complete and open investigation. Steel building have NEVER collapsed this way in the past nor in the time since 911 the world over. The extreme rate of fall of WT 1,2, and 7 seems to indicate that the support columns of all there buildings were compromised by a force other than fire. Video of the day shows unexplained rapid ejections of materials well below the main part of the failing structures. The videos quite possibly show evidence of controlled demolition. Sadly the video is all we have to work with at this point since all of the physical evidence was illegally hauled away and melted down.
J. Steve Dodds, PE
Mcminnville, OR
Education: BSEE, Oregon State Univ
J. Steve Dodds, PE
BSEE, Oregon State Univ
Mcminnville, OR
Earlier in my career, I have worked for a City government for 3 years and two different industries. For the last 34 years, I am engaged in my own Engineering firm. Even though my degree and my specialty is electrical, most of my work and income relates to the structural discipline (within expertise limits -- i.e., no high rises, schools, parking structures, etc.) I've worked with and can deal with all materials: soils, wood, masonry, reinf. concrete, steel, aluminum. I've even done forensics; 1 elect., 2 struct.
Well, I haven't read the official report. But I have watched many of the conspiracy theory videos. Also, I distinctly remember, nearly 9 years ago on the news report(s), the symmetrical collapse of BOTH towers, then the very underplayed (by comparison to the towers) PERFECTLY SYMMETRICAL collapse of Building 7. I thought at the time of controlled demolition and, by extension, an inside job. The gov's intent is to move on, but too many unresolved issues deserve proper focus, before all die.
Joseph C. Ferguson
Menlo Park, CA
Education: Bachelor Computer Engineering, Auburn U
Joseph C. Ferguson
Bachelor Computer Engineering, Auburn U
Menlo Park, CA
Graduated Brooklyn Technical High School, 1968, BCE Auburn University, 1986, CAD software developer 1986-present. Also a potter since 1969 and have experience with gas burners heating up kilns made of steel and fire-brick to 2300 degrees F. over 20+ hour periods.
Watching the towers reduced to neat piles of rubble on TV that day, what I saw did not fit with what I was being told. By the time I emerged from a state of shock a couple of weeks later, the evidence had been eliminated. Mr. Gage's presentation fits precisely with the empirical evidence and my materials experience. I feel relief from cognitive dissonance when I face the fact that those collapses could not have been caused by the jets crashed into those towers, no matter how much fuel was aboard.
Alan J. Rupp
Tallahassee, FL
Occupation: Engineer
Education: MS Electrical Engineering
Alan J. Rupp
MS Electrical Engineering
Tallahassee, FL
Occupation: Engineer
U.S. Army Signal Corps, '71-'74 - - University of Washington, BSEE - - Santa Clara University MSEE - - Thirty years in design engineering of analog integrated circuits.
"Building 2, the second building hit and the first to ""collapse"" was hit two thirds of the way up. It breaks off at the impact point and a photo shows it leaning over at 20 degrees. The pile driver effect is gone at that point. The top third of the building is no longer pressing down on the bottom two thirds. No load = no buckling. Imagine a tree in the woods being struck by lightning two thirds of the way up. The top third breaks off and falls over. Then, starting at the top of the remaining ""stump"" which is two thirds the height of the original tree, a wave of destruction starts and goes down at near freefall, spewing out wood chips and sawdust. Where did all this this energy come from?"
Bill Boggia, BEng
Ballater, Aberdeenshire, United Kingdom
Education: BEng Mechanical Engineering
Bill Boggia, BEng
BEng Mechanical Engineering
Ballater, Aberdeenshire, United Kingdom
I have 20 years post graduate experience as a structural engineer working in the offshore oil and gas, and laterally, renewable energy sectors. I have been running my own consultancy company for the last 10 years providing structural engineering services to offshore wind, wave and tidal energy projects.
The collapses of the towers appear to happen in a symmetric fashion at free fall velocity - indicating the use of demolition. Molten metal in the basement and columns sliced neatly at 45 degrees indicates the use of thermite. The collapse of Building 7 is particularly suspicious given that it was only hit by falling debris - and if was going to collapse at all - it certainly would not have been symmetrical - nor complete.Fire endurance tests with actual models failed to cause collapse. The NIST structural simulations - are not full simulations from the moment of impact to final collapse and the failure mechanisms seem to have been manually adjusted rather than relying on the pure physics capabilities of the software. The pulling forces on the perimeter columns by the sagging floors were adjusted' (NIST, 2005, p. 142) to cause yielding. A full and proper non-partisan peer reviewed set of analysis simulations has yet to be carried out. I suspect proper simulation will verify the physical model test results i.e. the buildings would not have collapsed due to aircraft impact alone.
Paul Kinzelman
Peralta, NM
Occupation: Computers/Aviation
Education: BS Elect Eng, Carnegie-Mellon Univ
Paul Kinzelman
BS Elect Eng, Carnegie-Mellon Univ
Peralta, NM
Occupation: Computers/Aviation
Consulting Computer Engineer and jet pilot, flying an air ambulance Lear Jet.
I've been impressed with the data that volunteers have brought forward. I'm not prepared to say what happened, I can say confidently only that what the government has said is what did NOT happen.
Gary Anderson, Registered Profe
Lakewood, CO
Occupation: Civil And Mechanical
Education: MS Civil Eng, Duke U; BS Mech Eng, WPI Mass 1966
Gary Anderson, Registered Profe
MS Civil Eng, Duke U; BS Mech Eng, WPI Mass 1966
Lakewood, CO
Occupation: Civil And Mechanical
BS - Mechanical Engineering, WPI- Mass. 1966; MS - Civil Eng., Duke Univ., NC. Design Engineer - Pratt & Whitney Aircraft; R&D Engineer - water and waste-water equipment manufacturer; 40+ years in design of water and waste-water treatment facilities.
Having worked on the design of aircraft jet engines, I know full well that the combustion of JP-4 and similar fossil fuels is incapable of creating temperatures sufficiently high to melt steel. - - - - The existence of smoldering steel weeks after the event is conclusive evidence that the true cause of the failure was NOT a jet-fuel caused fire. - - - - A free man is he who does not fear to go to the end of his thought. - - -- Leon Blum - (1872-1950) - - - - Let us free our minds. - - Gary Anderson, PE
Robert L. Sogge, PhD, PE
Tucson, AZ
Education: PhD Civil Engineering, U of Arizona
Robert L. Sogge, PhD, PE
PhD Civil Engineering, U of Arizona
Tucson, AZ
The background of Robert Sogge is unique in that they include training, teaching, research and practical consulting in the specific area of soil-structure interaction. Specifically he has made significant contributions in the areas of anchored sheet piles, laterally loaded piles, reinforced mat foundations systems, and buried arch culverts. His thin-arch designs have been verified by full-scale HITEC tests on a 28 ft span structure. With partners he founded a design-build company to construct such structures.
As to the 'conspiracy' theory, I don't get into it ' instead, I look at the failure of just Bldg #7 that came down at 5:23 pm after only being hit by a small 40 ft by 40 ft section of steel beam. The building constructed of steel came tumbling down. I, as a designing Civil Engineer, would not want to design with such a material if that were the case. So it is said to have failed by 'progressive failure'. Where is the research, conferences and study on this topic. Where is AISC in defending their product as they always used to do in comparisons to concrete structures? Where are our professional groups like ASCE on this topic? I notice that ASCE sponsored a 'paper' on the Pentagon Bldg failure ' but the study was a joke in that concrete walls were replaced by columns in the analysis. When the Teton Dam failed in the late 70's, the cause of the failure was investigated. The failure generated much research and subsequent conferences on Hydraulic Fracturing ' the culprit. Thank you for finally creating a voice for those of us who would like to correct the facts for the public and preserve the profession we work in and love.
Ben I. Andrus, B.S. Mech. Engr. Tech.
Glendale, MT
Education: BS Mech Engr Tech-ASU-Tempe Arizona
Ben I. Andrus, B.S. Mech. Engr. Tech.
BS Mech Engr Tech-ASU-Tempe Arizona
Glendale, MT
I was born in Kamas Valley Utah, grew up on a farm near Lava Hot Springs Idaho in a large family. Then served two years as a missionary in Finland, got my higher education at Ricks College, and then went on to get the degree in Mechanical Engineering Technology at Arizona State University in 1980. I took a job with the Boeing Company primarily as weight & balance engineer on the hydrofoil program with some time on airplanes and electronics (7 years total) before I became disabled by chemical sensitivities from an indeterminate combination of cigarette smoke, carpet out-gassing, solvents, synthetic perfumes, etc. at work, on the road, and in our mobile home. Thus, I moved back to the mountains where I am isolated from most normal social interaction, so the internet is a huge boon for me, since I have a positive ventilation system set up to exhaust my computer equipment to protect myself.
I had studied the previous incidents of Oklahoma Murrah building, the Waco massacre, Tonkin Gulf, Pearl Harbor, etc. so was prepared enough to recognize immediately when I saw on Fox satellite news that the towers went down on the morning of 9-11, that they were taken down by pre-planted explosives'the little bit of video they show made it blazingly obvious. And just as divulged by the news, it was a New Pearl Harbor event' but I knew few Americans comprehended the full meaning of that admission. We also heard later that day of the other building that collapsed. I am fortunate in having a wife who is likewise aware. I told all I knew my view, but most thought it impossible' or rather did not want to face what was obvious from the evidence. I heard fairly early of the molten metal in the basements and couldn't help suspect nuclear involvement, so was very interested when Steven E. Jones found thermite and then super-thermite. I cringed at his involvement as co-chair of the 911 website with Fetzer.
James M. Jones, Civil Engineerin
Tucson, AZ
Education: B.S., Metallurgical Engineering, UTEP
James M. Jones, Civil Engineerin
B.S., Metallurgical Engineering, UTEP
Tucson, AZ
I have worked as a metallurgical and failure analysis consultant for over 6 years. Currently perform air quality inspections, and plan reviews for the Pima County Department of Environmental Quality.
Considering the design and method of failure of the world trade center buildings and the evidence of the damage and debris from the building collapses it is clear that these structures underwent a high energy failure mechanism that cannot be attributed to a localized structural instability or heat induced by one or more collisions with a jet aircraft and the ensuing fires. As a concerned citizen I believe a full, complete and open investigation of the failures and the evidence of the twin towers, and world trade center 7 building collapse is vital and necessary to the security of the nation.
Anthony Acocella, Mech.Eng
Marlton, NJ
Education: Master's Mechanical Engineering
Anthony Acocella, Mech.Eng
Master's Mechanical Engineering
Marlton, NJ
Graduated from Drexel University with a Masters Degree in Mechanical Engineering. Work for a military contractor designing shipboard type cable assemblies.
I believe that the events are suspicious and I agree to an independent investigation.
Steven Merritt, PE
San Diego, CA
Education: MS, Structural Engineering, UC San Diego
Steven Merritt, PE
MS, Structural Engineering, UC San Diego
San Diego, CA
Practicing Structural Engineer and tax payer. I have designed steel high rise buildings for the past 8 years.
There seem to be a lot of unanswered questions and it would serve the greater good to re-open the investigation and do a more thorough job to remove any doubt.
David K. Shore, MS
Albuquerque, NM
Education: M.S. Engineering, U of Utah
David K. Shore, MS
M.S. Engineering, U of Utah
Albuquerque, NM
Jet aircraft performance engineer for 5 years. Construction, welding, steel fabrication, design for 20 years.
The building collapses appeared suspicious, and the report did not address adequately the questions that have been raised about the mode of failure. For the security of all future Americans, these questions must be investigated by an independent group of experts, not political operatives.
Simon Vaillancourt, Engineer
Montreal, QC, Canada
Education: B. Sc. Eng. Mechanical
Simon Vaillancourt, Engineer
B. Sc. Eng. Mechanical
Montreal, QC, Canada
'- Composite material fabrication technician - Aeronautical mechanical Eng. from E.T.S. Graduated in 2004 - Work for 2 years in the U.S.
I'm glad to finally see (a little late) a genuine scientific approach by multiple qualified professional sources not blurred by patriotic rose glasses'..
Jorge Zavala, BSET
Alameda, CA
Education: BSET, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo
Jorge Zavala, BSET
BSET, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo
Alameda, CA
Attended East Los Angeles and LA Trade Tech before transferring to Cal poly San Luis Obispo.
I hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 ' specifically the collapses of the World Trade Center Towers and Building 7.
Thomas Dickerman, Civil Engineer
Daly City, CA
Education: BS Civil Engineering
Thomas Dickerman, Civil Engineer
BS Civil Engineering
Daly City, CA
Suspicious!
David A. Remington, BSEE, MSEE
Boulder, CO
Education: BSEE, MSEE, MS Math, Univ of Colo
David A. Remington, BSEE, MSEE
BSEE, MSEE, MS Math, Univ of Colo
Boulder, CO
Have worked at Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, and Diablo Canyon Nuclear Plant. Currently run a business in Boulder Colorado.
It is obvious that these buildings were part of a controlled demolition. Anyone who can watch Richard Gage's presentation will be convinced. Our government owes us an explanation of how this could happen. The consequences of such an investigation would have far reaching effects on how our government regards it citizens.
Dana Curtis, Mech.Eng
Starksboro, VT
Education: Bachelor Mechanical Engineering
Dana Curtis, Mech.Eng
Bachelor Mechanical Engineering
Starksboro, VT
I am 28 years old, live and work in VT at a small engineering company.
I remember thinking, as I watched building 7 fall, that there was something strange. Those few small fires brought a building down so perfectly? A couple years ago, I was lying awake in bed, surfing the TV stations. I happened upon Loose Change being played on a local cable access channel. That sent me off into a fury of research into 9/11. In my mind, there is NO POSSIBLE WAY the building fell because of the plane impact/fire. Building 7's collapse explanation is so ridiculous I don't even know what to make of it. I hope that I can see some bit of truth and justice come to light in my lifetime.
Vincent C. Dileonardo, PE
Tampa, FL
Education: BME, Univ of Delaware 1996
Vincent C. Dileonardo, PE
BME, Univ of Delaware 1996
Tampa, FL
I manage my own Mechanical, Electrical, and Plumbing Engineering small business in Tampa, FL
Obvious demolition from the minute I saw Tower 2 go down on TV. Same with the others later that day.