The AE911Truth Petition
To the Members of the House of Representatives and of the Senate of the United States of America,
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT:
On Behalf of the People of the United States of America, the undersigned Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth and affiliates hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 – specifically the collapses of the World Trade Center Towers and Building 7. We believe there is sufficient doubt about the official story and therefore the 9/11 investigation must be re-opened and must include a full inquiry into the possible use of explosives that might have been the actual cause of the destruction of the World Trade Center Twin Towers and Building 7.
Featured Petition Signers
James Burns, MCIBSE, CEng
B Sc. Physics
The official story of the collapse of these buildings is not believable to anyone with a working knowledge of construction. It is in the interests of all building…
James Burns, MCIBSE, CEng
B Sc. Physics
Sheffield, South Yorkshire, United Kingdom
Chartered Building Services Engineer with design experience going back to the early 1970's. Initial degree was in theoretical physics and post graduate work in engineering and building services. I have a broad background experience in design, construction and installation. Have acted as professional witness and expert in building issues. Former Council member of the HVCA in the UK.
The official story of the collapse of these buildings is not believable to anyone with a working knowledge of construction. It is in the interests of all building professionals to get to the bottom of this. I would urge all professional bodies to swing their authority behind a call for a detailed and comprehensive investigation of the facts. There is something seriously wrong here.
Peter Liebold, Dipl.-Ing.
Degreed
Collapse of steel-framed buildings because of fire is nearly impossible. And a symmetrical collapse in free-fall-speed because of fire is absolutely impossible. About 300 hours of studying the…
Peter Liebold, Dipl.-Ing.
Degreed
Greiz, Thüringen, Germany
Diploma - Engineer of Ships-Electronics and Radiocommunication. Today working as Developer and seller of Software-Projects (with own business).
Collapse of steel-framed buildings because of fire is nearly impossible. And a symmetrical collapse in free-fall-speed because of fire is absolutely impossible. About 300 hours of studying the facts relating to Sept. 11 showed me clearly, that the mainstream-medias and the governments of USA and Germany (and other) were lying and that they are still lying today.
Matthew Taylor
Engineer
B.S. Civil Engineering, California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, 2010
Even to a layman, the collapse of WTC 7 looks exactly like a building demolition. If I prepared a report on a structural failure and didn't justify my…
Matthew Taylor
B.S. Civil Engineering, California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, 2010
Grover Beach, CA
Occupation: Engineer
I have a B.S. in civil engineering, and I am a licensed civil engineer in the state of California. I practice in the field of structural engineering, on both new designs and retrofits.
Even to a layman, the collapse of WTC 7 looks exactly like a building demolition. If I prepared a report on a structural failure and didn't justify my results and provide full data and calculations, models and tests, I would probably get fired. Yet NIST got away with this in their report on WTC 7. A truly scientific study on the collapse of tower 7 with peer review and no agenda or political bias should be performed.
Iman M. Ghaly, Architect
Bachelor of Science in Architecture
I have watched Mr. Gage on YouTube and was fully convinced with his theory. It's scientifically obvious that those high rise buildings were brought down by controlled demolition.…
Iman M. Ghaly, Architect
Bachelor of Science in Architecture
Cairo, Zamalek, Egypt
Name: Iman M.Ghaly - - Degree: Bacholar of Science in Architecture - - University: Faculty of Fine Arts - Helwan University - - Cairo - Egypt - - Nationality: Egyptian - - Years of experience: working as an architect from 1992 until present. - - Nature of Projects of expertise: Designing and working on several major multi-million budget projects most of which are residential developments, recreational facilities, hotels and resorts, sport facilities, etc.
I have watched Mr. Gage on YouTube and was fully convinced with his theory. It's scientifically obvious that those high rise buildings were brought down by controlled demolition. - - - - So, as an architect, I want to support your cause, even though I live in another part of the world (however it's directly influenced by that event which took place 10 years ago). And I want to be informed with all the new updates regarding the matter, and if there is anything I can possibly do to support your efforts I will be happy to do so. Thanks.
Marcio H. Gomes Da Cruz
B Arch; BS Geography, UNCC
Thermite? sulfur? molten steel? something doesn't add up here. Building 7 was demolished to shred evidence
Marcio H. Gomes Da Cruz
B Arch; BS Geography, UNCC
Miami, FL
Thermite? sulfur? molten steel? something doesn't add up here. Building 7 was demolished to shred evidence
John P. Allen, General Manager
Business/Media
BA Business, Cal State Fullerton
We need justice for those who passed on that horrific day and for all the living peoples in the world who've been affected by the 9/11 catastrophe
John P. Allen, General Manager
BA Business, Cal State Fullerton
San Diego, CA
Occupation: Business/Media
General Manager of Veterans Today Network, the largest independent network for U.S. Veterans on the net with over 500,000 unique visitors per month.
We need justice for those who passed on that horrific day and for all the living peoples in the world who've been affected by the 9/11 catastrophe
Marcin Garbacz Grazyna, Constultant/Arch
M.SC Architecture
I hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 ' specifically the…
Marcin Garbacz Grazyna, Constultant/Arch
M.SC Architecture
Richmond, VA
Architect; http://www.mgarbacz.com/
I hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 ' specifically the collapses of the World Trade Center Towers and Building 7.
Peter Jamtgaard, PE, SE
Civil/Professional/Structural Engineer
BS Civil and Environmental Engineering, Marquette University, 2003; Professional Master in Structural Engineering, Illinois Institute of Technology, 2005
There is absolutely no way WTC #7 could have collapsed in this manner without being imploded.
Peter Jamtgaard, PE, SE
BS Civil and Environmental Engineering, Marquette University, 2003; Professional Master in Structural Engineering, Illinois Institute of Technology, 2005
Honolulu, HI
Occupation: Civil/Professional/Structural Engineer
I have a BS in civil and environmental engineering and a Professional Masters in structural engineering. I'm licensed in four states as a professional, civil, and/or structural engineer. I have expert level skills in construction engineering, civil design, project planning, safety planning, scheduling, CAD/BIM management, manufacturing, detailing, and construction management. I have personally supervised, detailed, and engineered more than 100 steel deck erections in the Chicago area, including at least five 50-story office towers and the Soldier Field renovation. I have also designed and constructed bridges. I represent KAM Industries d.b.a. Cordeck as a member of the Steel Deck Institute Board of Directors (who develop the national building codes for steel deck.)
There is absolutely no way WTC #7 could have collapsed in this manner without being imploded.
Gary R R. Nolen
Architect (Retired)
Univ of New Mexico
Clear facts brings one to conclude that the collapse to the two WT towers were not the result of domestic air flights crashing into the towers and that…
Gary R R. Nolen
Univ of New Mexico
Fatima, Portugal
Occupation: Architect (Retired)
Master of Architecture degree + work history (1968 to 2007) Project designer, Project Architect. International Church design and restoration (with extensive condition assessment experience)following earthquake and hurricane damage to structures).
Clear facts brings one to conclude that the collapse to the two WT towers were not the result of domestic air flights crashing into the towers and that bldg. # 7 was a controlled demolition. The 2010 video by Electrical Engineer in the UK suggests round, anti-gravity, missile/drone as seen on live TV channel 4 broadcast on morning of September 11, 2001...worth investigating more in depth, in my opinion.
John Rexroat, Mfr. Engineer
Degreed
John Rexroat, Mfr. Engineer
Degreed
Walnut Creek, CA
Filipe S. Cunha
Architect
degreed & licensed
It was a delibered implosion. A building cannot fall the way it fell.
Filipe S. Cunha
degreed & licensed
Ponta Delgada, Portugal
Occupation: Architect
Graduated by the University of Lisbon. Worked in Lisbon and Paris.
It was a delibered implosion. A building cannot fall the way it fell.
Brian Mcalexander, Architectural Pr
B Arch
Simulations of building collapse vs. actual video, don't match. Building 7 is interesting.
Brian Mcalexander, Architectural Pr
B Arch
Cincinnati, OH
Practicing architect for 12 years.
Simulations of building collapse vs. actual video, don't match. Building 7 is interesting.
Petition Signatories
Leslie A. Pyeatt, PE
Angleton, TX
Education: BSCE
Leslie A. Pyeatt, PE
BSCE
Angleton, TX
Over 25 years experience in civil engineering and construction (mostly public works). Project Manager for Federal Demonstration Project and two APWA/Southern California award-winning projects in West Hollywood, California. Also served as Project Manager for a fire sprinkler subcontractor on building projects in Houston, Texas (including high-rise buildings in Houston and San Antonio).
The fact that both towers collapsed in their footprints, without any toppling of the upper floors, clearly indicates controlled demolition as the cause of the buildings' collapse, rather than structural failure. In my opinion, the collapse of the south tower (WTC 2) illustrates this idea most clearly. The airplane which hit this tower entered the south wall, and wreckage can be seen in the videos exiting the east wall. As a result, one would expect the damage to be worse near the southeast corner of the building, and any structural collapse should have occurred first at this corner. This should have resulted in the upper floors toppling toward the southeast. However, videos of the building's collapse clearly show it failing in a more or less symmetrical manner. - - - - In contrast, the north tower (WTC 1) was hit by the first airplane in the north wall, at almost a perpendicular angle to the north wall. And yet, the upper floors of this building leaned toward the south as the building collapsed. - - - - Likewise, there are two failure phenomena which cannot be explained by the pancake collapse theory. First, video of the collapse of the north tower shows the upper floors (approx. 10 stories) toppling toward the south. Yet, instead of falling to the ground relatively intact (as they should have done with no structure supporting them from beneath at that point, and nothing pressing down on them from above), they mysteriously disintegrated in mid-air. What forces (other than explosives) could have caused this? - - - - Second, a video exists which shows part of the inner core of the north tower still standing prior to the south tower's collapse. And yet, with only minor debris falling on it from the south tower, the remaining core structure disintegrates. Unless the video is faked (and I have seen no evidence of this), what would have caused the remaining core structure to collapse?
Andrew C. Mills, PhD
Lower Gwynedd, PA
Education: MS Eng.
Andrew C. Mills, PhD
MS Eng.
Lower Gwynedd, PA
Agricultural missionary in India 1956-1961 Water and Soil Specialist, Action for Food Production, India 1967-1971 Water Supply Specialist and Hydrologist in consulting firms in US 1972 to present B.S. in Forestry, Penn State 1952 Ph.D. in Soil Chemistry, University of CA-Davis 1967 M.S. Eng in Water Resources Engineering, U. of Michigan 1972
The appearance of the collapses and the lack of sufficient momentum to cause the rapid global collapse seen below the points of impact of Towers 1 and 2, imply that some type of planned demolition took place in those buildings. The collapse of WTC 7 was clearly a planned demolition.
Prasad Bhatt, President, Certa
Arlington Heights, IL
Education: Master's Mechanical Engineering
Prasad Bhatt, President, Certa
Master's Mechanical Engineering
Arlington Heights, IL
experience in design and testing fire/smoke dampers at elevated temperatures. operates UL recognized test lab for last 22 years.
Judging from video and reports, it is not conceivable that gasoline fire can melt the steel in a way it did in collapse of wtc buildings. Collapse of third building which was not even hit by planes is a total mystery.
Larry Rosenberg
Tahoe City, CA
Education: B.S., Mech. Eng, Syracuse University
Larry Rosenberg
B.S., Mech. Eng, Syracuse University
Tahoe City, CA
Graduated with a B.S. in mechanical engineering from Syracuse University. Worked for a large, CA based, employee-owned science & engineering company, conducting risk assessments on nuclear power plants.
While I understand the strategy of focusing on the WTC-7 building collapse, it is painfully obvious from just watching all three WTC buildings collapse that they were brought down by controlled demolition. There is absolutely no other possible explanation from a science and engineering point of view. Science has no agenda. The additional supporting evidence (squibs, thermate, eyewitness accounts, etc.) is very useful, but ultimately, not even needed to prove with 100% certainty that all three WTC buildings were destroyed by explosive demolition. A scientific/engineering analysis of video showing the collapse of the 3 WTC buildings is ultimately the only evidence required to prove with 100% certainty that all three WTC buildings were destroyed by explosive demolition. Again, science has no agenda.
Paul R. Kenyon, Engineering Cons
Bridport, VT
Occupation: Mechanical Engineer
Education: BSc Mechanical Engineering. Lafayette College, 1971
Paul R. Kenyon, Engineering Cons
BSc Mechanical Engineering. Lafayette College, 1971
Bridport, VT
Occupation: Mechanical Engineer
I'm a design mechanical engineer working with steel and other materials. My designs are of dynamic (moving) mechanisms meant to work in the real world and, as such, must follow the laws of the physics of moving bodies. My work involves fabrication of mechanisms and other parts often made by heating and gas welding mild steel and 4130 (chrom-moly) steel.
The collapse of any of the three WTC towers that fell on 9/11/2001 in NYC could not have happened as quickly as they did or as neatly as they did, straight down into their own footprint if gravity provided the only collapse energy. This means that the conclusions drawn by the US government and NIST are incorrect. The event is critically important, perhaps the most important event in US recent history. We must get this right.
Alexander R. Thorp, PE, PLS
Great Barrington, MA
Education: B.S. Civil Engineering, WPI
Alexander R. Thorp, PE, PLS
B.S. Civil Engineering, WPI
Great Barrington, MA
Physics was my favorite subject in high school, although I also enjoyed mathematics greatly. I attended WPI for engineering, and took courses in statics, dynamics, thermodynamics, etc., graduating BSCE with distinction, with an emphasis in environmental engineering. Following graduation, I have worked in water resource management, and most recently performing civil engineering and land surveying work, mostly associated with single family house construction. I am the owner of a small engineering and surveying firm in Great Barrington, MA. I have no particular experience with explosives. I don't watch TV.
The collapse of WTC was used as justification for an illegal unprovoked attack upon the people of Iraq, and an assault upon freedom and liberty at home and abroad. Scott Ritter, U.S. Marine, following 9/11, predicted our invasion of Iraq, and has further predicted a planned invasion of Iran. The U.S. government needed a reason to enter Iraq, and I believe 9/11 was it. I have watched Mr. Richard Gage's compelling video How the Towers fell, and I believe after watching it that he is correct. Controlled demolition, an inside job. A truly independent investigation is needed!
Richard Thurmond, BSEE, MSCENG
Cobb, CA
Occupation: Electrical & Computer Engineer
Education: BSEE, MSCENG, Univ. So. California
Richard Thurmond, BSEE, MSCENG
BSEE, MSCENG, Univ. So. California
Cobb, CA
Occupation: Electrical & Computer Engineer
I studied physics as part of my electrical engineering degree. Since graduating I have studied physics on the side and always had an interest in the subject.
I understand that buildings can't fall at free fall speed if some of the gravitational potential energy is used up in blowing out windows, bending columns. Also, it seems to me that a building would tip over rather than fall into its own strongest supports. It seems logical, then, that the buildings were helped. I would be interested in seeing whether the columns from the core were bent and twisted or cut in pieces by the destruction.
Rod G. Armstrong
Cupertino, CA
Education: B. Eng (Australia)
Rod G. Armstrong
B. Eng (Australia)
Cupertino, CA
Although I work in software, I have always had a strong interest (and some training) in mechanical and civil engineering.
The building collapses were clearly suspicious as was the complete lack of air force response. It was a crime, not an act of war, and there should have been a forensic investigation.
Adam Shaffer, BS
Edwardsville, IL
Education: BS
Adam Shaffer, BS
BS
Edwardsville, IL
I recently earned my B.S. in Mechanical Engineering from SIUE. Before this, I received 4 years training as an Information Systems Technician in the United States Navy. In addition, I spent some time studying computer Engineering at the University of Illinois.
The collapse of WTC 7 was an unambiguous and outstanding example of building implosion. It honestly baffles me how anyone could not see this. WTC 1 and WTC 2 were demolished in an unconventional fashion. Top-Down style demolitions are rare but not impossible. What intrigues me about WTC 1 and WTC 2 is their complete destruction. The contents of the building were turned into a fine dust.
Richard P. Sheridan, PE
New York, NY
Education: Civil Engineering
Richard P. Sheridan, PE
Civil Engineering
New York, NY
Born in The Bronx, New York 1946. Educated in catholic grammar, high school, and Manhattan College.
Only a controlled demolition would have cause the towers to come down in an almost perfect vertical fall. Only demolition would have caused window glass to be shot out hundreds of feet horizontally. It is a shame on the engineering profession that the ASCE hasn't challenged the official government position on 9/11. There are some malicious, greedy, power hungry people ruining our great nation, and attempting to enslave We The People.
John D. Kabitzke, BSChE
Des Moines, IA
Education: B.S Ch. E.
John D. Kabitzke, BSChE
B.S Ch. E.
Des Moines, IA
Chemical Engineering degree from Iowa State University. Worked as a Civil Engineer in the Air National Guard for 8 years and then changed career to Telecommunications.
Too many witnesses saying they heard explosions in the lower levels and too many unexplained events, such as, the collapse of Building 7 and the steel columns of the trade building appearing to have been purposely weakened.
John L. Mason, PhD
Portage, MI
Education: Ph.D. Electrical Engineering, Michigan
John L. Mason, PhD
Ph.D. Electrical Engineering, Michigan
Portage, MI
Attended Muskegon, MI Community College and University of Michigan (Ann Arbor) for BSE(Electrical Engineering) 1961, MSE (Electrical Engineering) 1962 Univ. of Michigan, MS(Physics) 1967 Univ. of Michigan, Ph.D. (Electrical Engineering) 1982 Univ. of Mich. Quality Assurance Engineer at Applied Dynamics(Ann Arbor) 1968- 1969, Product Development Engineer at Entrekin Computers of Fenton, Mich. 1969-1971, Associate Professor of Electrical Engineering at Western Michigan in Kalamazoo 1971-2004
Clearly, the building collapses appear to be in the same manner as those taken down by controlled demolition.
Greg M. Boyd, PE
Bethesda, MD
Education: BS & MS Civil Engineering, Univ of MD
Greg M. Boyd, PE
BS & MS Civil Engineering, Univ of MD
Bethesda, MD
Trained and worked as a machinist for 10 years. Worked for a ground water company prior to getting my M.S. then worked for a government contractor doing R&D work for 7 years. For the last 8 years I have been working for Fairfax County Public Schools supervising the contracting for infrastructure replacements (generators, light poles, electrical systems, etc.).
I find that people have an emotional reaction to the suggestion that controlled demolition brought down the 3 buildings, because of the implied involvement of elements within the government. This information conflicts with most people's desire to feel happy and optimistic, so that its acceptance is not easy.
Dane M. Ketner, Physical Science
Anchorage, AK
Education: Electrical Engineering
Dane M. Ketner, Physical Science
Electrical Engineering
Anchorage, AK
I live and work in Alaska. I graduated from the University of Alaska Anchorage with a bachelors in electrical engineering. My focuses are robotics and signal processing which I will pursue in graduate school next year.
Overwhelming physical/chemical evidence, eye witness testimonial, and common sense suggest that America deserves a new independent investigation. To start with, this new investigation should discard all theories of building collapse which violate conservation of energy (including the current 'official' theory).
Sherman J. Handberg
Duluth, MN
Education: B Mechanical Engineering
Sherman J. Handberg
B Mechanical Engineering
Duluth, MN
Worked toward my degree at U. of Minnesota, Duluth, then transferred to U. of Minn, Minneapolis. Studied Mechanical Engineering, and some Aeronautical Engineering. Received my degree in June, 1974. Worked at A.G.McKee Engineering company in Hibbing, MN for about 3 years.
After the planes hit, I thought: Well, that looks repairable. The twin towers stood up to the impacts well. The fires were smokey, but didn't look hot at all. I thought it was fishy when the towers collapsed, but eventually put it in the past. Until I saw one or two 9/11 videos and absorbed some facts, like the 9.5 seconds it took for the buildings to collapse (free fall speed); the molten steel in all 3 basements 6 weeks after 9/11; the way the lobbies were blown apart and the injuries people had from HIGH VELOCITY explosions. Jet fuel might make a low velocity explosion, but it wouldn't blow people's skin off. Building 7's steel beams were incredibly massive because of the electrical substation below it. They wouldn't allow it to collapse the way it did, without high explosives. We would've seen some unsymmetrical partial collapse somewhere among those 3 buildings, not 3 perfect collapses into their own footprints.
Dianne M. Treichler, PE
Loleta, CA
Education: BSE from University of Michigan, 1983
Dianne M. Treichler, PE
BSE from University of Michigan, 1983
Loleta, CA
Born 04/03/1961 in, Lynn MA to Leonard and Marjorie Treichler. Graduated June 1979 from Upper Merion Senior High School in King of Prussia, PA. Attended University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, from Sept 1979 to June 1984. Graduated with Bachelor of Science in Environmental Engineering, December, 1983. Licensed as a Civil Engineer by the State of California, Feb 1994 Employed by: The South East Michigan Council of Governments, 1984; The Traverse Group, Inc. 1985-1988; Winzler & Kelley, Consulting Engineers 1989 - 1997; Dianne M. Treichler, PE (self) 1997 - 2000 State of California, Department of Transportation 2000 - present
When I watched the towers fall on live TV, I thought the same thing - Planned Demolition. But then I heard the official reports and expert conclusions and thought, Well, I am not an expert in this field. They are. They must be right. I later began to hear rumors. I brushed them off as the ramblings of paranoid conspiracy nuts. I watched the PBS presentation on Why the Towers Fell and thought Well, that settles it then. Then I saw your web site. I viewed the Power Point Presentation. WOW! Now, I am blown away. Hopefully, with the upcoming elections, we can get a government administration willing to take a serious look into this heinous crimes and lay blame (and PUNISHMENT) on those who truly are guilty. (NOT THE INNOCENT CITIZENS OF IRAQ!)
John Schaefer, PhD
Arcata, CA
Education: PhD Stanford; MS San Jose State; BS MIT
John Schaefer, PhD
PhD Stanford; MS San Jose State; BS MIT
Arcata, CA
Semi retired. 20 years solar engineering and project management. Projects throughout US and Latin America. 20 years electrical and electronic design.
It's quite clear that the buildings cannot have come down as a result of airplane crashes. It's also quite disturbing that this crime has not been properly investigated by officials who should do so.
Dave M. Clifford
San Luis Obispo, CA
Education: B.S. Aerospace Engineering, Cal Poly SLO
Dave M. Clifford
B.S. Aerospace Engineering, Cal Poly SLO
San Luis Obispo, CA
Aerospace engineering graduate from Cal Poly SLO with emphasis on mechanics of composite materials. Currently not pursuing engineering profession, bartending.
It is a sad day for humanity when institutions are killing their own for conquest/monetary gain. The evidence clearly shows demolition was behind the collapse of all THREE towers.
Sachin S. Terdalkar, PhD
Fayetteville, AR
Education: PhD Mechanical Engineering, University of Arkansas Fayetteville
Sachin S. Terdalkar, PhD
PhD Mechanical Engineering, University of Arkansas Fayetteville
Fayetteville, AR
PhD in Mechanical Engineering. Aspiring to be a researcher.
I am an engineer and support your research. This is the biggest cover-up story in the history of mankind. If you can prove that the government is behind the collapse of these buildings we can prove that it is also responsible for the attack.
Nathan S. Lomba, PE, SE
Eureka, CA
Education: BS Civil Engineering, University of Colorado at Denver/Boulder, 1976
Nathan S. Lomba, PE, SE
BS Civil Engineering, University of Colorado at Denver/Boulder, 1976
Eureka, CA
Consulting civil/structural engineer with over 22 years in private practice (39 years total). My experience ranges from custom residential to heavy industrial structures. Some of my major project involvements include: lead civil/structural engineer on a $700 million project for the US Air Force, structural design engineer for a 41,000 sq. ft. pulp machine building, and resident engineer on a 550 MW Natural-gas fired power plant.Idaho PE, 1980Idaho SE, 1990California PE, 1987BSCE, 1976, University of Colorado, Denver/Boulder, COProfessional Affiliations:Member, American Concrete Institute (ACI)Member, American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)Charter member, Structural Engineering Instititute (SEI)Professional member, American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC)
I began having doubts about the official explanations for the collapse of the WTC towers soon after the explanations surfaced. The gnawing question that lingers in my mind is: how did the structures collapse in near-symmetrical fashion when the apparent precipitating causes were asymmetrical loading? The collapses defy common logic from an elementary structural engineering perspective. If you accept the argument that the fire protection covering was damaged to such an extent that structural members in the vicinity of the aircraft impacts were exposed to abnormally high temperatures, and if you accept the argument that the temperatures were high enough to weaken the structural framing, that still does not explain the relatively concentric nature of the failures.Neither of the official precipitating sources for the collapses, namely the burning aircraft, were centered within the floor plan of either tower; both aircraft were off-center when they finally came to rest within the respective buildings. This means that, given the foregoing assumptions, heating and weakening of the structural framing would have been constrained to the immediate vicinity of the burning aircraft. Heat transmission (diffusion) through the steel members would have been irregular owing to differing sizes of the individual members; the temperature in the members would have dropped off precipitously the further away the steel was from the flames'''just as the handle on a frying pan doesn''t get hot at the same rate as the pan on the burner of the stove. These factors would have resulted in the structural framing furthest from the flames remaining intact and possessing its full structural integrity, i.e., strength and stiffness.Structural steel is highly ductile; when subjected to compression and bending it buckles and bends long before reaching its tensile or shear capacity. Under the given assumptions, if the structure in the vicinity of either burning aircraft started to weaken, the superstructure above would begin to lean in the direction of the burning side. The opposite, intact, side of the building would resist toppling until the ultimate capacity of the structure was reached, at which point, a weak-link failure would undoubtedly occur. Nevertheless, the ultimate failure mode would have been a toppling of the upper floors to one side, much like the topping of a tall redwood tree, not a concentric, vertical collapse.For this reason alone, I rejected the official explanation for the collapse of the WTC towers out of hand. Subsequent evidence supporting controlled, explosive demolition of the two buildings is more in keeping with the observed collapse modalities and only serves to validate my initial misgivings as to the causes for the structural failures.
Jerome E. Liebler, BSEE
Science Hill, KY
Education: BSEE, Wayne State, MI
Jerome E. Liebler, BSEE
BSEE, Wayne State, MI
Science Hill, KY
40+ year career in electronic design with most recent projects designing digital signal processing hardware and software.
To me it has been obvious that controlled demolition and not plane crashes & fire were the causes of the WTC collapses since I saw the first TV reports on 9/11, 2001. The blatantly dishonest official story, the cover up and media efforts to hide the obvious are frankly very scary to me. A new and thorough investigation is absolutely needed, but it must be conducted by those outside the influence of the perpetrators. Perhaps this new investigation is a task for a foreign government, possibly Canada, or the UN.
Erik M. Soderlund, Chief Engineer
Hang Dong, Chiang Mai, Thailand
Education: BS Marine Engineering
Erik M. Soderlund, Chief Engineer
BS Marine Engineering
Hang Dong, Chiang Mai, Thailand
Mass Maritime Academy 1981 Currently sailing as Chief Engineer aboard the MV APL China.
Molten puddles of metal... Hot spots viewed from space weeks later... Where did that energy come from?
Daniel E. Walsh, PE
Rochester, NY
Education: BS Chemical Engineering, SUNY Buffalo
Daniel E. Walsh, PE
BS Chemical Engineering, SUNY Buffalo
Rochester, NY
Employed as an Environmental Engineer with the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation, Division of Air Resources for the past 22+ years. Previously employed in industry for 15 years.
The official explanation of the collapse of the World Trade Center towers makes no physical sense to me. I believe we need a new complete forensic investigation of the collapse that is not subject to political influence from any direction.
Frank J. Cullinan, PE
Mckinleyville, CA
Education: BS Civil Engineering
Frank J. Cullinan, PE
BS Civil Engineering
Mckinleyville, CA
My expertise is in structure construction of bridges and to a lesser extent demolition of bridges.
The buildings fell at or very near free fall speed and into their own foot prints! The second airplane went through the corner of the building, with most of the fuel burning outside the building. Furthermore, it did not hit the structural core. Yet it fell the same as the first tower!!! Impossible !!
Edward E. Knesl, PE, SE
Phoenix, AZ
Occupation: Civil, Structural
Education: MS Engineering
Edward E. Knesl, PE, SE
MS Engineering
Phoenix, AZ
Occupation: Civil, Structural
Full Master Degree study of Civil and Structural Engineering. Thirty five years of experience domestic and overseas in commercial and transportation projects : - Structural Design and Analysis - Construction Administration and Management - Plan Review - Special Inspection
We design and analyze buildings for the overturning stability to resist the lateral loads with the combination of the gravity loads. Any tall structure failure mode would be a fall over to its side. It is impossible that heavy steel columns could collapse at the fraction of the second within each story and subsequently at each floor bellow. We do not know the phenomenon of the high rise building to disintegrate internally faster than the free fall of the debris coming down from the top. The engineering science and the law of physics simply doesn't know such possibility. Only very sophisticated controlled demolition can achieve such result, eliminating the natural dampening effect of the structural framing huge mass that should normally stop the partial collapse. The pancake theory is a fallacy, telling us that more and more energy would be generated to accelerate the collapse. Where would such energy would be coming from ?
Larry Erickson, PhD
Pismo Beach, CA
Education: PhD, Virginia Polytechnic Institute & SU
Larry Erickson, PhD
PhD, Virginia Polytechnic Institute & SU
Pismo Beach, CA
Retired NASA engineer (33 years). Performed research in the fields of structural dynamics, aerodynamics, aeroelasticity and flutter.
Serious technical investigations by experts seem to be lacking from the official explanations.
Mark R. Phillips, Mech.Eng
Santa Rosa, CA
Education: BSME, Cal Poly, SLO
Mark R. Phillips, Mech.Eng
BSME, Cal Poly, SLO
Santa Rosa, CA
I graduated summa cum laude, no. 1 in my class from Cal Poly State University in San Luis Obispo, CA in 1991. I worked for a year as an intern prior to graduation and for 12 years afterwards as a machine designer of turbo expanders.
There are numerous unexplained phenomena that lead me to reject the official conspiracy theory advanced by the government. Some of the most compelling are the explosive projections observed from well below the collapse zone and the discovery of molten metal during the collapse and in the debris. Any theory that ignores these important pieces of data will always be viewed as illegitimate by any serious investigator.
Adam Kingsnorth, BE(Hons)
WestcliffOnSea, Essex, United Kingdom
Education: BE(Hons), Electronics and Computer
Adam Kingsnorth, BE(Hons)
BE(Hons), Electronics and Computer
WestcliffOnSea, Essex, United Kingdom
Well-rounded engineering career, specializing in electronics, instruments, control and computers. Mechanics/Design/Environmental Studies/Materials Science/Mathematical modeling and law were also studied.
The collapses were framed by the media and official investigations as if there was little doubt in their conclusions on collapse. Taking a fresh look at the collapses 3 years ago woke up my rational thinking and education to the fact that the evidence and scientific numbers didn't add up in the disciplines of mechanics and materials. They made it easy for people to imagine that the initial events alone could actually cause the WTC 1, 2 and 7 to collapse as they did.
Tony Hepp, Design Engineer
Spring, TX
Education: B.S. in Mechanical Engineering, U of AR
Tony Hepp, Design Engineer
B.S. in Mechanical Engineering, U of AR
Spring, TX
Before earning a Masters of Divinity degree in 2007, I worked as a manufacturing engineer for two years and as a design engineer for four years. My interests include energy generation, theology, philosophy, science, and weapons.
Yahweh once said through King Solomon, The first to plead his case seems right, until another comes and examines him (Prov 18:17, NASB). The unwillingness of the federal government to allow third-party examination of the 9/11 events and evidence raises many red flags in my mind. I find the inside job arguments, especially those pertaining to building 7, to be cogent.
Edward Ussery, BSME, MMS
Anaheim, CA
Education: BSME-UCLA, MMS-Harvard Medical Sch.
Edward Ussery, BSME, MMS
BSME-UCLA, MMS-Harvard Medical Sch.
Anaheim, CA
I worked at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory on the MAGELLAN Venus Probe in Navigation Systems. I ran computer simulations of deep-space trajectories for orbit accuracy analysis studies. Additionally, I worked at Rockwell International Space Systems for two years on the Space Shuttle, in Ground Support Systems. I worked for five years at Ford Motor Company, Transmissions and Chassis Division in product engineering for the E4OD, the transmission that went into F-series and E-series trucks. While at Harvard, I worked at the Boston Heart Foundation, testing a prototype computerized blood pressure monitor. I created an educational 3D animation of the embryologic heart for Harvard Medical School's Center for Education Technology as well. I am currently working as a teacher while I blog at Powers and Morrison, develop an educational system I began research on while at Harvard, and am a writer.
I strongly doubt the official story on 9/11. I was at the WTC on Labor Day, 2001, and the event disturbs me greatly to this day. I linked the Loose Change website to my blog back in June of 2006 in order to spread its message to others, have seen Improbable Collapse, and the final cut of Loose Change. I have also seen the film, Zeitgeist, and have linked all of these important films to my widely-read blog. I have read a considerable amount of Dr. Stephen Jones' report, and went to see him back in February. I am preparing my official statement on the matter, to be presented by YouTube video, which will be linked to my blog at PowersandMorrison.com sometime in April, 2008
Tom Westbrook, Enginering Staff
Mesa, AZ
Education: BS Electrical Engineering
Tom Westbrook, Enginering Staff
BS Electrical Engineering
Mesa, AZ
I have a bachelor's degree in electrical engineering and have worked in the high tech industry for 15 years for companies such as Motorola and Intel.
I have been solving highly complex technical issues for many years and have many questions about 911. My biggest question that I would like answered is how do you get molten steel from kerosene?
Dr. Robert T. Mote, PhD, BEng (Hons)
Calgary, AB, Canada
Education: BEng (Hons)
Dr. Robert T. Mote, PhD, BEng (Hons)
BEng (Hons)
Calgary, AB, Canada
'+20 years experience in structural design. Special interest in dynamic and explosion behaviour of structural elements and foundations.
By observation, I could never understand the 'convenient' vertical collapse at the base due to an extreme event at height. I was most concerned by the third tower collapse, totally unrelated! Why didn't other buildings fall? I have watched the documentaries and agree many questions remain unanswered.
Gavin Ellis
Ganges, BC, Canada
Education: Degreed
Gavin Ellis
Degreed
Ganges, BC, Canada
Electronic engineer interested in structural information regarding the Twin Towers and the real truth behind the demolition. Also wondering why non biased media still states the demolition as a terrorist attack. I guess they must be referring to the us republican government as terrorists!?
It hugely concerns me that mass genocide can be committed by a government on it's own country; looks very much like a detonation to me, amazing how the buildings fall straight down, and you can even see charges blowing out the sides as the collapse occurs. Buildings designed to withstand the impact, and yet they fall? separate testimonies please!!! it must be hard to admit to the truth of killing that many people, but then i guess cover ups are a common political move.