The AE911Truth Petition
To the Members of the House of Representatives and of the Senate of the United States of America,
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT:
On Behalf of the People of the United States of America, the undersigned Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth and affiliates hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 – specifically the collapses of the World Trade Center Towers and Building 7. We believe there is sufficient doubt about the official story and therefore the 9/11 investigation must be re-opened and must include a full inquiry into the possible use of explosives that might have been the actual cause of the destruction of the World Trade Center Twin Towers and Building 7.
Featured Petition Signers
Moises Colon, Engineer - Energ
Electrical Engineering
My decisions are always based on logic, facts, and evidence. When you look at the MASSIVE amount of facts and evidence around 9/11, a reasonable, rational person can…
Moises Colon, Engineer - Energ
Electrical Engineering
Carolina, PR, Puerto Rico
Electrical, Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Experience. Drafting and Engineering Assistant Experience while in college.
My decisions are always based on logic, facts, and evidence. When you look at the MASSIVE amount of facts and evidence around 9/11, a reasonable, rational person can only come to one conclusion. It wasn't just the planes...
Paul Elliott
Metallurgical Engineer
BS Metallurgical Engineering, University of Missouri Rolla, 1999
People think jet fuel must be hot if it can lift airplanes into the air, but in reality, it must burn inside a metallic engine without damaging it,…
Paul Elliott
BS Metallurgical Engineering, University of Missouri Rolla, 1999
Eureka, MO
Occupation: Metallurgical Engineer
BS Metallurgical Engineering, University of Missouri-Rolla, 1999. I've been working as a metallurgical engineer for over 15 years, supporting various manufacturing and testing processes for the aerospace and defense industries.
People think jet fuel must be hot if it can lift airplanes into the air, but in reality, it must burn inside a metallic engine without damaging it, so it doesn't burn hot enough to even melt structural steel. Most of the jet fuel hitting the twin towers flashed off on impact, leaving little left to finish off the towers. And what exactly was supposed to have caused world trade 7 to come down? There have been a few intense fires in steel frame buildings, and they all leave the frame standing when they're over. Fire cannot explain the near-instant collapse of world trade 7.
Mike A. Swatek, Principal Engine
BS Mechanical Eng - Univ of Oklahoma
The case made in these documentaries is virtually 100% against the official record and points to some very disturbing likely possibilities. A proper investigation is needed before some…
Mike A. Swatek, Principal Engine
BS Mechanical Eng - Univ of Oklahoma
Claremore, OK
I became familiar with steel structures as a draftsman for Kerr McGee designing offshore drilling rigs from 1979-82. After spending 3.5 years to earn a BS mechanical engineering degree at the University of Oklahoma in 1985, the oil industry was in a deep recession. The next couple of years were spent developing and designing robots and industrial manipulator arms. 1988-90 were interesting years at Rockwell Rocketdyne developing rocket engine systems for Star Wars. Since 1990 the technical challenge of electrical submersible pumping systems for the oil industry has been my profession. Currently as Principal Engineer at Baker Hughes International I mentor young engineers and serve as a technical adviser for a wide range of system and mechanical challenges for the BHI Centrilift products.
The case made in these documentaries is virtually 100% against the official record and points to some very disturbing likely possibilities. A proper investigation is needed before some very dark elements in our government are able to deliver us all the way down the road to serfdom.
J Scott Eddy, AIA
Architect
B Arch, University of Southwestern Louisiana, 1982
I hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 ' specifically the…
J Scott Eddy, AIA
B Arch, University of Southwestern Louisiana, 1982
Jackson, MS
Occupation: Architect
I'm the President of Barlow Eddy Jenkins Architects in Jackson MS. I have 30 years experience as an architect and I'm licensed in multiple states. I specialize in healthcare architecture and master planning. I have worked with medical institutions to evaluate existing facilities, to re-configure inpatient beds to maximize operational efficiency and to create specialized inpatient centers and outpatient service which focus on major patient groups requiring unique service delivery and support. I manage the overall production operations of our staff and firm. I was a Hurricane Katrina damage assessment volunteer on the MS gulf coast in 2005-2006.
I hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 ' specifically the collapses of the World Trade Center Towers and Building 7.
Marc A. Degiovanni, Ccc
Culinary Arts
A.S., Culinary Arts, Balsams CAP
In October 2001, I approached the United States Consulate General's Office in Z'rich, Switzerland. I had testimonial and physical evidence placing Mr. Atta and five other persons in…
Marc A. Degiovanni, Ccc
A.S., Culinary Arts, Balsams CAP
Santa Fe, NM
Occupation: Culinary Arts
Field - Culinary Arts Apprentice Chef, class of 2005: Balsam's Hotel, Dixville Notch, NH (2002 - 2005) Sous Chef, A Single Pebble Restaurant, Burlington, VT (2006 -2007) Personal Chef, Deeridge Farms, East Aurora, NY & Wellington, FL (2007-2008) Sous Chef, Mu Du Noodles, Santa Fe, NM (2008 - present)
In October 2001, I approached the United States Consulate General's Office in Z'rich, Switzerland. I had testimonial and physical evidence placing Mr. Atta and five other persons in Zurich in July of 2000. Without being able to say more than a couple of sentences, I was told There is no evidence that anyone involved in the events of September the Eleventh has ever stepped foot in Switzerland. There will be no further investigation. I have doubted the official story since this time. The work of AE911truth.org and others is uncovering considerable evidence and casting considerable doubts on the official stories. I would like to see another investigation on the collapses of all three WTC buildings that fell on September 11, 2001.
Oulamine O. Ahmed, DPLG
DPLG
I m just not sure 100% that a plane could do that and i need some body demonstrate me that a plane could do that a research should…
Oulamine O. Ahmed, DPLG
DPLG
Essaouira, Essaouira, Morocco
Architect dplg from Institut P'dagogique d'Architecture de Nantes France ,1982 Stage d''tudes approfondies en urbanisme UER G'ographie de Poitiers Poitiers ,France ,1983
I m just not sure 100% that a plane could do that and i need some body demonstrate me that a plane could do that a research should be done for to help people if it happen again.
Gary M. Weinstein, PhD
Ph.D., Civil Engineering, Polytechnic Un
If one chooses to significantly study all of the evidence and to think critically on the same, the only logical conclusion that can be drawn is that the…
Gary M. Weinstein, PhD
Ph.D., Civil Engineering, Polytechnic Un
Brooklyn, NY
25 years of professional engineering experience in the field of civil and geotechnical engineering in both the US public and private engineering sectors, in the construction industry as well as in the halls of academia, nationally as well as abroad.
If one chooses to significantly study all of the evidence and to think critically on the same, the only logical conclusion that can be drawn is that the official story of 9/11 put forth, in its entirety simply cannot be true from any perspective. It is an impossibility. Additionally, there is overwhelming evidence, including eyewitness statements, photographic and videographic records, timelines, scientific and engineering data, irrefutable laws of physics, and the like which directly and unequivocally refute the official story of 9/11. All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as being self-evident. - Arthur Schopenhauer, German philosopher (1788 ' 1860) There will come a day when our children & grandchildren will look us in the eyes and ask us what we did and what action we took when we learned of the truth of 9/11 . . . 'He who passively accepts evil is as much involved in it as he who helps to perpetrate it. He who accepts evil without protesting against it is really cooperating with it.' - Martin Luther King, Jr. (1929 ' 1968)
Matthew Skjonsberg, PhD
Architect
Taliesin/Frank Lloyd Wright School of Architecture, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology-Zurich (ETH)
I first become skeptical about the official 9/11 narrative while watching the NOVA episode on the subject with my mentor, engineer E. Thomas Casey - who did the…
Matthew Skjonsberg, PhD
Taliesin/Frank Lloyd Wright School of Architecture, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology-Zurich (ETH)
New York, NY
Occupation: Architect
Having founded collab architecture in 2001, I co-founded and have been project leader from 2007-2012 at West 8 New York, and since then am a PhD researcher at Swiss Federal Institute of Technology-Lausanne, where I was a founding member of the Laboratory of Urbanism, and am a researcher at NYU Institute for Public Knowledge.
I first become skeptical about the official 9/11 narrative while watching the NOVA episode on the subject with my mentor, engineer E. Thomas Casey - who did the calculations for Frank Lloyd Wright's Guggenheim Museum, among other projects - during which Mr. Casey expressed the depth of his disappointment with this particular piece of misinformation by quietly wiping a tear from his eye and simply saying, 'it is not true.'
Thomas L. Brake, BA, BS, MS
Pe (Retired)
MS Civil Engineering, New Mexico State University, 1986
Considering the arrangement and size and strength of the concentric columns arrangement, the high velocity of free-fall of the towers did not seem to be correct.
Thomas L. Brake, BA, BS, MS
MS Civil Engineering, New Mexico State University, 1986
Silver City, NM
Occupation: Pe (Retired)
Associate degree in Electronic Engineering Technolgy. BA Biology/Chemistry, BS Geological Engineering, MS Civil Engineering, 1986.
Considering the arrangement and size and strength of the concentric columns arrangement, the high velocity of free-fall of the towers did not seem to be correct.
John Sotelo
Degreed
John Sotelo
Degreed
La Mesa, CA
I am a UCLA mechanical engineering graduate. I went to medical school and am now a physician.
John E. Aistrup
Claims Officer
After reviewing countless pieces of evidence and reading the official 9/11 Commission Report, I am not convinced that the Twin Towers and WTC 7 were brought down by…
John E. Aistrup
Wellingborough, Northamptonshire, United Kingdom
Occupation: Claims Officer
I am a claims officer and I deal with predominantly personal injury claims. I understand how claims are made as well as having family members who have worked as claims loss adjusters on behalf of insurance companies in the building claims sector here in the UK.
After reviewing countless pieces of evidence and reading the official 9/11 Commission Report, I am not convinced that the Twin Towers and WTC 7 were brought down by jet planes and office fires. There needs to be a full inquiry as to how these buildings collapsed at near free fall speed, even at the risk of finding out that the official version is incorrect and the repercussions which it may entail. The truth is likely to be uncomfortable, but American citizens and the world population need to know.
Frank E. Stratton, PhD
Civil Engineering, Ph.D., Stanford Univ.
After viewing videos of the collapse of both the Twin Towers and Building 7 and after carefully studying the Official 911 Commission Report and the technical report prepared…
Frank E. Stratton, PhD
Civil Engineering, Ph.D., Stanford Univ.
Anacortes, WA
I am presently retired as a Professor of Civil & Environmental Engineering, and currently licensed in both California and Washington States as a Civil Engineer and in Washington State as an Environmental Engineer.
After viewing videos of the collapse of both the Twin Towers and Building 7 and after carefully studying the Official 911 Commission Report and the technical report prepared by FEMA and the Structural Division of the American Society of Civil Engineers, I am convinced that the airplane impacts did not by themselves cause the buildings to collapse -- particularly for Building 7, which was never impacted by an airplane. It appears that internal explosives must have caused the buildings' destruction, and the American People have the right to know who was responsible for this horrific act.
Petition Signatories
Manogran Govender, Pr Eng, BEng, MBL
Durban, KwaZulu Natal, South Africa
Education: Pr Eng; BEng (UDW); MBL (UNISA)
Manogran Govender, Pr Eng, BEng, MBL
Pr Eng; BEng (UDW); MBL (UNISA)
Durban, KwaZulu Natal, South Africa
22 years experience in civil engineering, strategic planning and management consulting to various public and private sector clients in South Africa
The three WTC buildings offered little or no resistance to collapse into its footprint at freefall. The Pentagons strike left office furniture and a open book intact although officially - the intense fires were supposed to have vaporised metal. Windows on either side of the impact hole in the Pentagon wall where the wings should have crashed into were left intact.
David C. Owens, BSME
Mcalester, OK
Education: B.S.M.E., Union College
David C. Owens, BSME
B.S.M.E., Union College
Mcalester, OK
26 1/2 years as U.S Army civilian. 15 years R&D on large caliber cannon. 7 years as Army Proving ground Test Director. 4 1/2 years at Defense Ammunition Center.
The official explanation of the collapses makes no sense to a competent engineer.
Larry T. Martines
Hobe Sound, FL
Education: BS Applied Physics Hofstra University NY
Larry T. Martines
BS Applied Physics Hofstra University NY
Hobe Sound, FL
Retired engineer/physicist with expert experience in radar and sonar development plus working experience in chemistry, heat treating, metallurgy, and automated warehouse design and construction.
As an experienced engineer/physicist with over forty years of working experience, including warehouse design and construction projects it is extremely difficult for me to accept the notion that the destruction of the WTC buildings were not due to controlled demolition.
Greg L. Weinfurtner, Electronic Desig
Albany, OH
Occupation: Electronic Design/Computer Design & Admi
Education: AEE Hocking College / BSS '94 Ohio Univ.
Greg L. Weinfurtner, Electronic Desig
AEE Hocking College / BSS '94 Ohio Univ.
Albany, OH
Occupation: Electronic Design/Computer Design & Admi
I am a retired Electronic Design Specialist and Computer Specialist, 53 years old, male. At my work, I used computers in design of circuits and PC boards. I also use them to consider stress forces, material suitability and sizes for construction of many types of machinery, small buildings and appropriate design factors. These are mostly small items, not large buildings, but I understand the concept behind the large building structural design. I am American, Constitutionalist, Free Man, anti-communist, Prolife, Born again Christian and willing to live for my country!
I believe that the buildings were intentionally brought down by pre-planted explosives and that the public was deceived by the use of non commercial jets. Building #7 is the Achilles heel, where you can here the count down to raze it, but it was not hit by any jet or missile. Also the Pentagon was not hit by a 767 or 757; there is just not enough of a hole in the building. I believe that it was a small cruise missile or other type of weapon.
Joseph P. Verrette, Nuclear Systems
Chester, NH
Education: Marine Engineering Operations
Joseph P. Verrette, Nuclear Systems
Marine Engineering Operations
Chester, NH
Marine Engineering and Power Plant Operations including Nuclear Systems.
How can two planes knock down three steel framed buildings and how could those buildings fall at the rate of gravity with no resistance?
Larry H. Brownstein, BS
Culver City, CA
Education: BS Electrical Engineering
Larry H. Brownstein, BS
BS Electrical Engineering
Culver City, CA
I have a bachelor's degree in electrical engineering. I have worked as a computer engineer and software engineer for over 20 years with companies such as Hughes Aircraft Company and Cadence Design Systems.
Building 7 collapsed at free-fall acceleration. It was far from the North and South Towers so it should have remained structurally sound. We need to explore why it fell. We need to explore why NORAD was unable to intercept any of the four airplanes. We need to explore the evidence that thermite was found in the WTC dust. 911 was the reason for going to war. We are still at war because of 911 so we need to know the truth.
Nils Johan A. Johansson
Karlskrona, Blekinge, Sweden
Education: Master of science Engineering Physics
Nils Johan A. Johansson
Master of science Engineering Physics
Karlskrona, Blekinge, Sweden
Working as system developer, programming C++. Holds degree in Master of Science in Engineering Physics at Uppsala University Sweden. Have a great interest in Physics.
It is obvious that they (building 1,2 and 7) has been blown up. The free fall acceleration and symmetrical collapse is impossible to get only using fires and flying debris. The rapid onset of collapse and the molten steel are other issues. The official reports do not hold any water. Evidence of nanothermite (explosives) was found in the dust proven by Niels Harrit.
Michael J. Simister
Dallas, TX
Education: BS Electrical Engineering
Michael J. Simister
BS Electrical Engineering
Dallas, TX
I graduated from the University of Cincinnati with a degree in electrical engineering. I was in New York the day of the 9/11 attacks and witnessed the destruction of the twin towers first hand.
Typically, when trying to scientifically investigate the unknown cause of an event... a hypothesis is formed and tested. If it is shown that the hypothesis cannot be disproved it can be considered a possible theory. Some theories are however, better than others. Theories are often scrutinized over and compared against one another. I feel that the evidence that has been presented to me regarding the collapse of building 7 opens the possibility of better theory than the one that is currently accepted. It is my opinion that a re-evaluation of the destruction of the world trade center buildings is needed.
John J. Tobak, EE
Bernardsville, NJ
Education: M.S., Electrical Engr., Stevens Tech
John J. Tobak, EE
M.S., Electrical Engr., Stevens Tech
Bernardsville, NJ
I am an engineer with over 10 years of experience in Electrical Engineering including the design of digital circuit boards for military applications. Design experience includes component trade studies and selection, schematic entry, PWB layout, verification testing for digital board designs, and the generation and testing of VHDL code for CPLD and FPGA designs. U.S. Citizen with a Secret Security Clearance.
The testimonies of eyewitnesses, such as the firefighters who were on the scene, have been ignored by those who have propagated the official explanation as to how the three buildings collapsed.
Charles Moulton
Knoxville, TN
Education: MS Engineering, Univ TN
Charles Moulton
MS Engineering, Univ TN
Knoxville, TN
masters degree electrical engineering with minor in mathematics from University of Tennessee 1964. Registered Engineer license until retirement. Two patents issued.
The government's investigation and conclusions are a complete fabrication and violate the laws of physics. The unanswered questions are so numerous and the misinformation so vast that a serious investigation by reputable scientific personnel is required.
Ralph R. Jordan, PE
Anchorage, AK
Education: BS Civil Engineering, University of Alaska Fairbanks
Ralph R. Jordan, PE
BS Civil Engineering, University of Alaska Fairbanks
Anchorage, AK
I provided general civil engineering, construction management, plan review, and engineering for small structures in the 1980's and early 1990's.
I had a college professor in structures who once said, and I paraphrase, Structures don't collapse from the mistakes that engineers design for....there are enough factors of safety to compensate for that...they collapse from what engineers completely miss designing for. - - - - When the towers collapsed, I was shocked and surprised, but attributed the collapse to the idea that...well...the engineers wouldn't have taken into account a large plane hitting them. Years later I discovered that they were indeed designed for a 707 hitting them. That got me thinking! - - Having spent many agonizing hours designing the structure for a church, I felt certain that the engineers of the towers would have overdesigned their structure to, if nothing else, still be standing until the last little old lady in a wheel chair escaped, unharmed. - - - - Call it gut feeling, with some practical engineering experience, but the idea of the tower collapses and especially the building 7 collapse being caused mainly by fires are suspect. The true cause or causes of these total failures certainly need to be re-investigated.
Mark Goretsky, PE
Plainview, NY
Education: degreed & licensed
Mark Goretsky, PE
degreed & licensed
Plainview, NY
Born in Kiev, Ukraine in 1936. Lived through WW2 in Siberia. Graduated as Mechanical Engineer in 1955. Emigrated to Israel in 1972. Emigrated to US in 1986. Got a PE license in NY. Worked as Power Plant Engineer.
Michael A. Mcdonald, BEng (Hons)
New York, NY
Education: BEng Hons, Engineering, Royal Naval Engi
Michael A. Mcdonald, BEng (Hons)
BEng Hons, Engineering, Royal Naval Engi
New York, NY
32 years experience. Electrical Control Systems and Distribution Systems for Iron and Steel Industry, Coal Mining. (9 years) British Royal Navy. Lieutenant Marine Engineering Officer (10 Years) Engineering Consultant New York. Electrical Control and Distribution Systems for Movable and other Bridges and Tunnels (16 years)
I observed the entire event and both collapses from my office window of 110 William Street facing West. What I saw bears no resemblance to what is portrayed as the mode of failure. When the top of the South Tower fell away to the East and down, I fully expected to see the jagged remains of the floors beneath still standing. I was taken aback when the smoke cleared and learned that the entire building had collapsed. It did not make any sense to me then and still makes no sense now.
Anthony Novak, BSEE
Bangkok, Bangkok, Thailand
Education: BSEE
Anthony Novak, BSEE
BSEE
Bangkok, Bangkok, Thailand
Over 25 year experience in the hydrocarbon processing industry. Design, construction, and operation of production, processing, terminal, and distribution facilities.
When the twin towers collapsed was in North America working on a project with one of the 7 sisters oil majors at the time. I watched the buildings come down with my colleagues. We were a team of engineers from various disciplines including civil and structural. Our immediate thoughts were that only controlled demolition could produce such a result. It is time for the truth to come out!
Joseph W. Miller, PE
Manchester, MO
Education: BSME
Joseph W. Miller, PE
BSME
Manchester, MO
Actively self employed consulting engineer specializing in restaurant design of mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems. Awarded 3 patents. Semi-finalist contestant on American Inventor 2nd series. Previously 25 years industrial design experience.
The appearance of controlled demolition by use of explosives is more than overwhelming when viewing the collapse of the Twin Towers. The evidence of the vertical cuts on the remaing standing columns is very powerful and conclusive. I have researched jet that crashed at Skranston,PA. and find there are many inconsistencies with the crash scene as compaared to other similar jet crash scenes, the lack of black box data only being one of many. I have also researched the crash data at the pentagon site and found there many holes in the official explanation of this crash as well. There are far too many unanswered questions and omission of facts in the official reports for them to have any credibility.
Charles Goyette, B.S.M.E., B.S.E.E., MEd Math
Austin, TX
Education: B.S.M.E., B.S.E.E., MEd Math
Charles Goyette, B.S.M.E., B.S.E.E., MEd Math
B.S.M.E., B.S.E.E., MEd Math
Austin, TX
I am a seasoned engineering professional and a newly certified teacher in mathematics for the state of Texas. I have built products for a host of applications in the aircraft engine, defense, and commercial software industries. My professional career spans twenty years working in the mechanical, electrical, and software engineering disciplines.
The most blatant evidence that virtually anyone can understand with the help of a high school science background or reasonable common sense and intelligence is the fact that a modern steel-framed building cannot collapse at free-fall speed on its original footprint without the help of high explosives. The collapse of Building 7 especially defies any other remotely plausible explanation. An unprecedented engineering failure, a symmetric and orderly collapse, and a debris field totally consistent with a controlled demolition effecting three separate structures on the same afternoon. The odds of this happening in a fashion consistent with our official government-endorsed conspiracy theory defy my imagination!
Randall Manyen, BSME
Houston, TX
Education: BSME
Randall Manyen, BSME
BSME
Houston, TX
Experienced Mechanical Engineer with expertise in thermodynamics, heat transfer and stress analysis.
Neither the collisions, explosions or the subsequent fires were sufficient to cause the Twin Towers to collapse at freefall speed into their own footprints. The official story also does not explain the collapse of Building 7.
David Chen, PhD
Irvine, CA
Education: PhD, EE, U of Ill at Urbana-Champaign
David Chen, PhD
PhD, EE, U of Ill at Urbana-Champaign
Irvine, CA
BS, MS, PhD in EE from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Worked at various aerospace companies doing artificial intelligence work, networked, real-time systems, and network security. Currently an Associate Technical Fellow at the Boeing Anaheim, California site, working on network security.
NIST & the US congress should be ashamed for the poor investigation. Thanks to the architects & engineers of this site for carrying the torch for truth.
Mark E. Miller, BSEE
Fulton, MD
Education: BSEE, Penn State, 1986
Mark E. Miller, BSEE
BSEE, Penn State, 1986
Fulton, MD
Graduated from Penn State University with a BS in electrical engineering. I have designed a number of circuits and software algorithms in various embedded systems for the industrial controls industry.
It is apparent and obvious to any open-minded individual that all three World Trade Center buildings could not have collapsed in the manner described in the official report. All three buildings were obviously imploded in a highly technical and coordinated manner, well beyond the capabilities of any terrorist group.
Patricia L. Seitz, PE
Lititz, PA
Education: Architectural Engineering - Structural
Patricia L. Seitz, PE
Architectural Engineering - Structural
Lititz, PA
Experience in structural engineering, with a strong interest in physics. I'm also a private pilot.
Based on my knowledge of building structures, physics and chemistry, it simply does not make sense that events which occurred on 9/11 were as our media/government have proclaimed.
Kerry A. Sartain, BEE
Acworth, GA
Education: BEE, Elec Engr, Georgia Tech
Kerry A. Sartain, BEE
BEE, Elec Engr, Georgia Tech
Acworth, GA
Have worked in control systems engineering for 40 years with Georgia-Pacific, Sandwell Engineering, Sartain Associates, M&M/Mars, Olin Chemicals, and JE Sirrine Engineers. Engineer, Lead Engineer, Staff Engineer, Project Manager.
The official analysis of the WTC building collapses does not account for observed data regarding the way the buildings came down. In addition, the collapse of building 7 is not sufficiently explained. It is my opinion that the simple collapse of steel columns supporting the upper portion of the two buildings (purportedly due to weakening by fire) and the subsequent fall of the upper section of each building would not generate the massive, immediate expulsion of debris in all directions from the buildings, and at the rate and distance from the buildings as was observed and recorded.
Scott Ragsdill
Rockwall, TX
Education: BS Mechanical Engineering
Scott Ragsdill
BS Mechanical Engineering
Rockwall, TX
Non Destructive Testing experience. Mechanical Analysis experience. Common Sense experience.
I have always thought the collapses defied logic and physics, since the moment they occurred.
James S. Fajcz, P.Eng, CMRP
Brunswick, GA
Education: Civil Engineering
James S. Fajcz, P.Eng, CMRP
Civil Engineering
Brunswick, GA
Graduate from Lakehead University in 1994 and licensed professionally with the Professional Engineers Ontario (PEO) in 1999.
The amount of dust surrounding the buildings and as they collapsed, is evidence to me just in viewing this to prove there is no pancake theory, otherwise they would have been stacked up one on top of each other, or the wreckage would have been a huge pile of steel and broken concrete (not dust). Also, one of the towers was leaning over at quite an angle just as it started to collapse, and this leaning never continued. If it was a conventional building collapse, it would have fallen over, but it never made it to the ground without getting destroyed. Oh, and the fact that all these buildings fell at free-fall speed. Clearly controlled demolition. Building 7 is a clear example of controlled demolition, with large bangs and other claims by officials that the building was going to come down.
Patricia A. Ormsby
Denver, CO
Education: B.S.Chem.E., U. of Colo., Boulder
Patricia A. Ormsby
B.S.Chem.E., U. of Colo., Boulder
Denver, CO
Upon receiving my BS in Chem.E. in 1980, I studied Linguistics at University of Michigan graduate school and have worked abroad as a translator of technical documents since 1984.
Because I consider the collapse of the three high rises at near free-fall speeds to be evidence of something else having gone on behind the scenes that day, most likely controlled demolition, even otherwise intelligent progressives consider me a tinfoil hatter now, most probably because of the recent National Geographic special. This is sad, but I believe that in time the psychological need to believe in the official theory will diminish, and the truth will be widely acknowledged. The most compelling evidence was broadcast worldwide repeatedly, ad nauseum. It will eventually be undeniable.
Nick Maniatis, Engineering Cons
Portland, OR
Education: BSIE - Arizona State University
Nick Maniatis, Engineering Cons
BSIE - Arizona State University
Portland, OR
I've found that the greatest asset to my Engineering education has been practical experience, continued education, inquisitiveness and the willingness to step back from all situations and stand in my common-sense corner... and to assert logical questions from that reference point.
Within 10 minutes of witnessing the collapses via public television, it was obvious to me that these 3 (three) collapses were showing definitive characteristics of precise detonation demolition. AND, what's with the 3rd WTC building... that was definitely brought down by demolition charges. There's no coincidence here. Immediate doubt!
Robin B. Chase, Engineering Staf
Tucson, AZ
Education: Engineering, University of Maryland
Robin B. Chase, Engineering Staf
Engineering, University of Maryland
Tucson, AZ
Graduated 1969 with degree in Electrical Engineering with studies in physics, nuclear physics, chemistry.
I don't believe the myths about the collapse of the three buildings. I believe it was a controlled demolition. Similarly, I don't believe that a passenger plane hit the Pentagon. I believe it was a cruise missile. I also question the rationale for a complete air defense stand down during the event.
Warren (Xiang) X. Guan, Vp Of Engineerin
San Francisco, CA
Education: BS Computer Science & Engineering, University California at Davis, 2003
Warren (Xiang) X. Guan, Vp Of Engineerin
BS Computer Science & Engineering, University California at Davis, 2003
San Francisco, CA
I have been working at my current job ever since I graduated. My line of work involves designing, writing up and maintaining a modern web 2.0 site. I specialize in Ruby on Rails on MySQL with open-source technologies.
The planes did not cause the collapse of the buildings; explosives did. The WTC buildings collapsed in a way very similar to a building rigged for controlled demolition. The official story did not adequately explain the explosions that many witnessed and heard at ground zero; the government even tried to deny it. There are just too many coincidences of events leading up to 9/11, starting with planes not intercepted to military personnel playing war games. It's not hard to see that those responsible are amongst those who benefited the most from this tragedy, including but not limited to big oil and private reconstruction contractors.
Sam Nejad, Engineering Cons
Geraldton, WA, Australia
Education: BSc Engineering
Sam Nejad, Engineering Cons
BSc Engineering
Geraldton, WA, Australia
Degree from Aberdeen University, Scotland 1979. Principal Structural Engineer. Specialist in steel structures. One of the principal structural engineers for Lysaght Steel. Designer/certifier of several thousand steel buildings over 30 years. Currently designing steel structures all around Australia & some internationally.
ONE steel building collapsing concentrically...very unlikely. TWO falling on their own footprint...ridiculous! THREE, on the same day in the same place? IMPOSSIBLE. For the first time in history 3 steel skeleton structures collapse for, supposedly due to some fires. But the fires are so small that they are only visible here & there. If the fires were so hot, the glass would have melted/shattered long before the steel making the so-called inferno clearly visible at every opening all around the buildings. The damage due to the planes was eccentric, so why was the collapse concentric? How did 3 steel buildings, allegedly in a condition of unstable static equilibrium, collapse in stable dynamic equilibrium? IMPOSSIBLE. I put aside all the ways in which it might have been done, Modern explosives placed at critical points would have done it. But put that all aside: The fact is that they were brought down; the physics & structural principles are incontrovertible. The method & reasons etc can be nutted out later. The 'squibs' which are officially claimed to be dust/smoke exhausting have too high a velocity for pumping exhaust...they emit at the velocity of explosive shock waves, equally all the way around. Just one other structural observation: At the Pentagon one evidence was supposed to be the bent over light-poles...so neatly leaning; from a 500mph aircraft impact?! Those light-poles would have been folded at the impact point, ripped out and left in a mangled mess some hundreds of metres away! So they were either toppled by small charges, or pulled over by ropes tied to a truck (the previous evening?). There is more structural observations I could make, but the above have not been stressed enough on your site, hence my comments. Please update your site to include/emphasize the above observations. Regards, Sam Nejad.
Jamal Mouline, Engineering Cons
Durham, NC
Education: BS Mechanical Engineering ENSEM France
Jamal Mouline, Engineering Cons
BS Mechanical Engineering ENSEM France
Durham, NC
Embedded Software Engineer of 15-year experience with global telecommunications companies.
The science community needs to have full access to all available data, including audio and video recordings, in order to reach a solid explanation of what happened to WTC7 as well as to flight 77, both events having so far the weakest justification from the official story Gathering a database of all available witness testimony would certainly greatly help Seeking truth about 911 should make America stronger at the end
John Nevin, B.E.E., M.S.
Brooklyn, NY
Education: B.E.E., M.S.
John Nevin, B.E.E., M.S.
B.E.E., M.S.
Brooklyn, NY
I am a born and bred New Yorker, electrical engineer, computer scientist. Having worked in a variety of industries throughout my career, I consider myself well versed and seasoned.
I worked in the WTC for nearly 12 years. I lost a lot of friends and would be dead myself if I had not resigned from that job months before 11 Sep. I feel like I owe it to them to know the truth, and to support good people who seek it.
James Vogt
Keene, NH
Education: Bachelors of Electrical Engerineering
James Vogt
Bachelors of Electrical Engerineering
Keene, NH
Graduated from Univ of NH in 1979. Design engineer for Ratheon Missile Systems Division. Self employed as programmer since 1985.
After 5 semesters of physics in college it is clear to me that these buildings were brought down via controlled demolition.
Robert J. Mcnamara, BS
Arvada, CO
Education: B.S. Ceramic Engr, Missouri School Mines
Robert J. Mcnamara, BS
B.S. Ceramic Engr, Missouri School Mines
Arvada, CO
Thirty year experience Engineering professional. Primarily as Corporate Manager. Also 5 years experience Consulting Engineer. Presented Expert witness testimony Re: Ceramics testing, use, and applications. District and Federal Courts.
Entire event needs a full. technical evaluation. I would hope that a truly independent group could be organized to conduct the evaluation without any assistance of Government.
Michael T. Dimercurio, PE
Newtown, PA
Education: MS, Mechanical Engineering, MIT
Michael T. Dimercurio, PE
MS, Mechanical Engineering, MIT
Newtown, PA
Michael DiMercurio, P.E., has over twenty-five years of project management and claims experience in the engineering and construction industry. Mr. DiMercurio has worked around the world on a wide variety of projects and is an experienced construction project manager, project controls expert and construction contracts expert in difficult negotiations with construction contractors and owners in adverse situations. Mr. DiMercurio's projects have included combined cycle power, circulating fluidized bed coal power, chemical process plants, cryogenic gas plants, commercial facilities and entertainment projects in both union and non-union environments. As a construction claims expert, Mr. DiMercurio has analyzed a wide variety of construction projects involving delay, damage claims, change orders, and project management issues. Mr. DiMercurio has extensive experience in owner claim defense, managing contractor invoice payment issues, backcharges to contractors, and counterclaim assertion to contractors. On the contractor's side, Mr. DiMercurio has asserted and recovered millions of dollars in claims for contractors suffering inefficiencies, hindrances, delays, poor coordination and defective engineering. Mr. DiMercurio was an honors graduate of the U.S. Naval Academy and MIT, and as a Navy nuclear operator, has both process plant operations and nuclear and fossil construction experience. DiMercurio is author of nine naval fiction books including VERTICAL DIVE and EMERGENCY DEEP.
The towers were designed to be hit by fully loaded jets. Would the designers be so negligent as to forget that those jets would be loaded out with fuel? Why have other steel skyscrapers burned, some over a dozen stories for hours and not collapsed? Why did the towers fall at free-fall speed? Why were the steel remains of the columns at bedrock melted?